| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Atherosclerosis and Lipoproteins |
From U.C.O. di Clinica Medica Generale e Terapia Medica (N.F., N.A., G.G., R.G., G. Guarnieri, C.G.), Dipartimento di Scienze Cliniche Morfologiche e Tecnologiche, University of Trieste, Trieste, Italy; Cardiovascular Center (M.F.), A.S.S. no 1 Triestina, Trieste, Italy; U.C.O. di Neurologia (N.C.), Dipartimento di Medicina Clinica e Neurologia. University of Trieste, Trieste, Italy; Blood Transfusion Center (L.U.), A.S.S. no 1 Triestina, Trieste, Italy; Department of Mathematics and Informatics (L.T.), University of Trieste, Trieste, Italy; Department of Surgery (T.B.), University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, Ne.
Correspondence to Nicola Fiotti, MD, U.C.O. di Clinica Medica Generale e Terapia Medica, Strada di Fiume, 447, 34149 Trieste, Italy. E-mail fiotti{at}units.it
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods and Results One hundred fifty patients referring to vascular diagnostic centers for suspected carotid atherosclerosis (at ultrasound examination: 110 positive, 40 negative) and controls (n=110) have been genotyped for MMP-9 PM. After controlling for risk factors, allelic and genotype frequencies were significantly different among the groups, with significant prevalence of long microsatellites in patients with carotid atherosclerosis. Long microsatellites (settled as 22 to 27 repeats) were associated with carotid atherosclerosis (odds ratio [OR], 5.2; 95% confidence interval [CI], 2.9 to 9.2), compared with controls; an independent case control study on patients with coronary atherosclerosis confirmed such result. Binary logistic regression showed that hypertension, long microsatellites in MMP-9 PM and smoking habits were variables accounting for the difference between ultrasound-positive patients and controls. Long microsatellites were also associated to plaques with thin fibrous cap and echolucent core (OR, 13.1; 95% CI, 1.6 to 100). These alleles were slightly more represented in female patients (
2 test=0.019; OR, 2.7; 95% CI, 1.2 to 6) but not associated with other risk factors. Plasma MMP-9 levels were related neither to MMP-9 PM nor to plaque type, and were related to gender and extension of atherosclerosis in carotid arteries.
Conclusions The number of repeats (
22 CA) in the microsatellite of MMP-9 promoter, but not MMP-9 plasma levels, is associated to carotid atherosclerosis and particularly to plaques with a thin fibrous cap.
Higher prevalence of long microsatellites (
22 CA repeats) in MMP-9 promoter was found in patients with ultrasound evidence of carotid atherosclerosis and, among them, in carriers of plaques with a thin fibrous cap and echolucent core. This PM was independent of known risk factors for atherosclerosis and did not influence MMP-9 plasma levels.
Key Words: atherosclerosis carotid arteries MMP-9 polymorphism stroke
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
20 neutral zinc-dependent endopeptidases, with different patterns in substrates specificity.6 MMPs were identified in atherosclerotic tissue, and MMP-9 in particular was observed in unstable and, to a lesser extent, in stable atherosclerotic plaques.4,7 MMP-9 activity in atherosclerotic plaques might induce monocyte8 and smooth muscle cell (SMC)911 migration and proliferation, degrade extracellular matrix, therefore contributing to thinning and fissuring of the fibrous cap of plaques.1214 Modulation of MMP-9 expression occurs through transcription factors and, likely, a genetic polymorphism (PM) in the promoter, namely the microsatellite (Cytosine-Adenine, CA)1327 at
90 position,15 affects transcription and, putatively, plays a role in the susceptibility to atherosclerosis. This microsatellite was proposed to facilitate the transition of B-DNA in Z-DNA, thus assisting the opening of the double strand and transcription. Studies on mice showed that even small differences between alleles (from 20 to 24 CA repeats) can account for a 30-fold increase in MMP-9 expression.16 The majority of the studies agreed that an increasing number of repeats is associated with increased expression.1517 Therefore, a high number of repeats, putatively accounting for higher expression, could promote plaque growth and possibly influence the structure of plaque. This study aimed to assess the association between microsatellites in MMP-9 promoter and carotid atherosclerosis and the prevalence of plaques with thin a fibrous cap and homogeneously echolucent core, identified as type 1 of the Gray Weale classification. Also, MMP-9 plasma levels were performed and analyzed.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Patients
Consecutive in-patients and out-patients visiting 2 noninvasive vascular diagnostic centers were studied. The control population consisted mainly of a group of blood donors attending the Blood Transfusion Centre of the Hospital of Trieste (Italy).
Ultrasound Assessment of the Carotid Arteries
Extra-cranial carotid arteries were examined with color Doppler ultrasound sonography. The scanning protocol entailed the longitudinal scanning of the near/far walls of the right and left carotid arteries at the distal common carotid artery, carotid bifurcation, and proximal internal carotid artery. Plaque was classified according to Gray Weale et al.18
Laboratory Determinations
The details of the method for the MMP-9 genotyping polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and capillary analysis have been previously published.19 Plasma MMP-9 levels have been determined with an R&D System Quantikine ELISA kit according to the instructions provided by the manufacturer.
Confirmatory Study
A group of patients with coronary atherosclerosis was compared with a control population. Patients with coronary atherosclerosis were selected among those admitted to the Emergency Unit of Trieste (Italy) for acute coronary syndrome.20 The control population consisted of healthy volunteers attending the Blood Transfusion Center of the Trieste Hospital (Italy) or subjects referring for minor transient problems to the Outpatients Clinics of the Internal Medicine Department of the University of Trieste.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 test P<0.0001) and directly comparing control group with ultrasound-positive patients (P<0.001), controls with ultrasound-negative patients (P=0.004), and ultrasound-positive and ultrasound-negative patients (P=0.019) (Figure 1). Although the first mode was set, for all 3 groups, at 14 repeats, the second mode was at 21 repeats for controls and ultrasound-negative patients, and at 22 for the ultrasound-positive patients. Ultrasound-positive women had a different allelic distribution than men (
2 test P=0.019), with approximately twice the prevalence of microsatellites with 22 or more repeats (odds ratio [OR], 2.66; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.16 to 6).
|
Multiple comparisons have been performed to detect exactly the alleles (or the group of alleles) more prevalent in patients with carotid atherosclerosis, compared with controls. Taking into consideration the Bonferroni correction, alleles with 21 or more repeats were significantly associated with carotid plaques. However, the prevalence of alleles with 21 repeats was higher in controls than in patients and, more relevant, the 95% CI or the OR of 21 or more repeats was significantly lower than that of 22 or more, as seen in the gap between the confidence intervals (Table 1). Standardization for gender and age, to account for gender difference in MMP-9 PM, did not change the results. A receiver-operator curve (ROC) (Figure 2A) was plotted to verify the changes in sensitivity and specificity of each midpoint. ROC confirmed the weak statistical association of 21 repeat allele with carotid atherosclerosis, compared with longer microsatellites.
|
|
Genetic frequency, considering only the length of the longest microsatellite, gave similar results (Table 2). When the cut-off was set between 20 and 21 repeats, the OR was 2.2 (95% CI, 1.3 to 3.7) and when set between 21 and 22, the OR was 7.6 (95% CI, 4.0 to 14.5). Both ways of grouping were effective in identifying alleles associated with carotid atherosclerosis but, similar to allelic frequencies, the CIs were substantially different, making carriers of 21 repeats as the longest microsatellite at the lowest risk for carotid plaques. This point was also confirmed by direct comparison of 21 versus 22 repeats (OR, 10.1; 95% CI, 3.8 to 27.4; and OR, 18; 95% CI, 4.6 to 70.5 for allelic and genetic frequency, respectively).
|
None of the risk factors analyzed in this study was associated with this polymorphism when analyzed as an ordinal or dichotomous variable (data not reported), and association of carotid plaques with MMP-9 PM was observed in both sexes (
2 test P=0.624). Binary logistic regression (stepwise method) showed that the variables accounting for the difference between cases and controls were hypertension, smoking habit and MMP-9 (Table II, see http://atvb.ahajournals.org).
MMP-9 PM and Type 1 Plaques
Fifteen type 1 plaques were detected throughout the ultrasound assessments; none of the risk factors was associated with this type of plaque. The allelic frequency was significantly different in patients with type 1 plaques, compared with patients with other type of plaques or controls. Within positive ultrasound patients, the risk of presenting a type 1 plaque is increased by >3 times in carriers of 22 or more repeats (OR, 3.33; 95% CI, 1.508 to 7.356). Analyzing the genetic frequency, except for 1 patient with a genotype with 14/14, all patients carried at least 1 allele with 22 or more repeats (Table 2). No significant association was detected with the other types of plaque; however, there was a trend in reduction of OR from echolucent to echogenic plaques (Table 3;
2 test P=0.007).
|
Plasma MMP-9 Levels
No difference was detected between patients and controls (controls 41 [3585 ng/mL]; negative ultrasound patients 34 [2271 ng/mL]; and positive ultrasound patients 44 [2488 ng/mL]; P=0.887). No relationship was noticed between MMP-9 plasma levels and genetic polymorphism using linear univariate correlation (Pearson R=0.036, P=0.716) or when patients were categorized according to the number of repeats in carriers of
22 or <22 (P=0.913). Within all patients, no differences were detected between plaque types and plasma values of MMP-9 (Table 3) or between MMP-9 plasma level and number of areas affected by atherosclerosis (Kruskal-Wallis test P=0.418). A significant, but weak, correlation (Pearson test) was demonstrated, however, only for the relationship between MMP-9 plasma levels and number of areas affected by atherosclerosis (Figure 3). Within patients, multivariate stepwise analysis showed that only sex (men 54 [32114]; women 36 [1957]) and the number of affected areas were the determinants of plasma MMP-9 levels (cumulative R2 0.134, P=0.026).
|
Independent Replication of the Study
The genotyping was successful in all patients (n=98, men=58%, age 69±12 years) and controls (n=116, men=60%, age 68±13 years), and the results of the replication are reported in Figure 1B. The data confirm the pattern observed in carotid atherosclerosis: compared with controls, patients have an increased prevalence of longer microsatellites (P<0.0001). Also, when the proportion of alleles with >21 repeats was considered, according to the evidence from carotid atherosclerosis, the results were similar (32 versus 12%,
2 test P<0.0001; OR, 3.3; 95% CI, 2.0 to 5.3). Data on genetic frequency were quite similar (
2 test P<0.0001; OR, 3.9; 95% CI, 2.2 to 7.1).
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
60% of patients were carriers of at least 1 allele putatively at high risk and ultrasound-negative patients had a 30% prevalence, whereas the prevalence in controls was <15%. A remarkable similarity was observed between the allelic frequency of coronary and carotid patients. This is not surprising, because the majority of patients with carotid atherosclerosis lesions are also carriers of coronary heart disease. Several studies have documented a prominent role of MMP-9 in atherosclerosis development and complication. These studies used different approaches: genome-wide scans,23 genetically engineered mice,24 autopsy,25,26 and pharmacology studies.27 Nevertheless, the role of MMP-9 PM in susceptibility for atherosclerosis has still to be established. Although 1562 C/T PM has provided contradictory results, we have focused on the microsatellite PM, showing its association with progression of IMT and of constrictive remodeling.19
The results of the present study confirm the evidences from genetically engineered animal models and clinical evidences in humans. Whereas extreme effects in knockout mice, ie, either full or absent expression, documented the role of MMP-9, in humans, functional polymorphisms might help understanding how the different expression of the same protein accounts for genetic susceptibility for atherosclerosis. The absence of MMP-9 in knockout mice accounts for a reduced atherosclerotic burden into aortas of mice, whereas little is known on how the MMP-9 expression affects the development of carotid atherosclerotic plaque.
Another similarity between animal and human atherosclerosis is that the MMP-9 expression in both is not responsible in itself for atherosclerosis, being that classical risk factors are required: hyperlipidemia in knockout mice and hypertension or smoke in patients. The very same risk factors have been also identified by other studies.28,29 Interestingly, smoke30 and hypertension31 can induce the MMP-9 expression, but not by hyperglycemia,32 whereas data on hypercholesterolemia are not conclusive.
Another important finding is that the very same long microsatellites seem to be associated with ultrasound features of carotid plaques, namely, the thin fibrous cap and echolucent core characterizing the type 1 plaque of the Gray Weale classification.
These plaques, associated to a higher prevalence of vascular events and alleged to be prone to rupture or erosion, might link this MMP and its polymorphism with the development of atherosclerosis events.
In our study, 22 or more CA repeats in 1 allele identifies 93% of plaques with thin fibrous cap classified as type 1, an increased risk of >10 times. The mechanism linking MMP-9 PM with the plaque structure can only be inferred. It involves increased expression of the MMP, increased degradation of the matrix, apoptosis,33 and, therefore, shaping of a thinner fibrous cap. Also, Pollanen showed a relationship between genetic PM of MMPs and structure of fibrous cap. At least the size of a plaque rupture is different according to the haplotype of MMP-9 and MMP-3.26
The same factors, matrix degradation and SMC apoptosis, might also be effective within the plaques. Formation of a lipid core of a plaque is determined by the confluence of extracellular lipid into a unique core. The amounts of matrix and SMC within the core determine the echogenicity.34 Our data are in good agreement with this hypothesis. The fact that in multivariate analysis MMP-9 PM is the main factor accounting for type 1 plaque adds to a possible role in determining the ultrasound characteristics of the plaques.
Plasma levels of MMP-9 in our study are not different in patients and controls and, in the positive ultrasound patients, in carriers of different plaque type. Also, MMP-9 PM did not account for a different plasma level. A study from Blankenberg et al showed that MMP-9 plasma levels predict the occurrence of future vascular events and were associated to the 1562 C/T genetic PM.35 Our results, on the contrary, do not support a role of MMP-9 plasma level in atherosclerosis susceptibility, or in plaque type or in relationship with polymorphism. The possible explanation for such discrepancy could be in the different study size and in the different end points.
Other factors, related to the difficulties in assessment of MMP-9 plasma levels, might further explain our contradicting results. An important issue in analyzing plasma MMP-9 levels is that enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) technique for this protein measures at once pro MMP-9, the active form, and complexes MMP-9/TIMP; therefore, a genuine assessment of the relationship between circulating level and expression as well as of other variables might be blunted by this low specificity, especially considering the high TIMP-1 levels in patients with atherosclerosis. Another possible explanation of the correlation of MMP-9 plasma levels with disease extension is that MMP-9 is contained in tertiary granules of neutrophil granulocytes and increased levels might reflect their priming during contact with plaques. The results of multivariate analysis showing that only number of areas affected by plaques in the carotid arteries account for the plasma levels seem to support this explanation. To overcome these pitfalls, large numbers of participants are required: with the data obtained from this study,
1200 subjects and patients had to be enrolled to observe a statistical difference between patients and controls.
Study Limitations
Whereas the difference was significant between patients with and without carotid atherosclerosis, the latter group was also significantly different from healthy controls. This result can have some explanations, such as either patients with symptoms requiring carotid ultrasound assessment have either atherosclerosis in other arteries or, maybe, other conditions requiring the MMP-9 activity.
The controls were not evaluated for carotid atherosclerosis with ultrasound. Some false-negative controls might have been introduced, although this should have resulted in a conservative estimate of the risk. This analysis studies only the longest microsatellite, assuming it accounts for an expression more than double than that observed in shorter ones.16 We do not think it resulted in an oversimplification, because comparison of allelic and genetic frequencies gave quite similar results. One has to consider that the number of possible genotypes is very high, and there are likely minimal differences in both the MMP-9 expression and prevalence of atherosclerosis.
In conclusion, the polymorphism of MMP-9 is a further tool for investigation of matrix remodeling during atherosclerosis. The advantages of assessing MMP-9 PM is that it allows the study of the human disease (rather than of animal models) and, in the clinical setting, is associated to a ten-fold increased risk of developing a thin fibrous cap plaque in the carotid arteries.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received August 4, 2005; accepted March 9, 2006.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
ATVB Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2006 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |