Atherosclerosis and Lipoproteins |
From the School of Animal and Microbial Sciences (C.J.M., P.D.W.), University of Reading, Reading, UK, and the William Harvey Research Institute (M.J.C.), St Bartholomews and Royal London Hospital School of Medicine and Dentistry, London, UK.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: apolipoprotein E LDL receptor knockout mice atherosclerosis distribution
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The true value of the new models, however, depends on the extent to which their disease resembles that occurring in human arteries. The present study addresses this similarity; more specifically, it is concerned with the nonuniform distribution of disease within the vasculature. The patchy occurrence of human atherosclerosis has attracted considerable attention because it demonstrates the existence of significant local risk factors. The determination of lesion distributions in models is an important test of the similarity to human disease and also indicates whether the models can be used to investigate localizing factors. The issue is particularly important for knockout mouse models because of their widespread and increasing use and because they could be used for investigating local risk factors at the single gene level.
The distribution of lesions has previously been studied in apoE knockout5 6 7 and LDL receptor (LDLR) knockout8 mice. In both models, disease preferentially affects the following: the aortic root, coronary ostia, and proximal coronary arteries; the lesser curvature of the arch and branches off it; the brachiocephalic trunk, carotids and subclavians; the branch ostia of the abdominal and thoracic aorta (the abdominal ostia being affected early and the thoracic ostia being affected much later); and the iliac bifurcation.4 8 9 10 11 12 13 However, the distribution of lesions around branches has not been systematically examined. This is a significant omission: it is not sufficient to demonstrate that disease occurs near branch points because it can have diametrically opposed distributions within such regions under different circumstances, probably reflecting important differences in underlying mechanisms. Thus, lesions occur downstream of branch ostia in immature human aortas14 but develop in a more lateral or upstream distribution at later ages, with the downstream region becoming spared.15 16 17 The downstream distribution has been observed in some animal models,18 19 and the more upstream distribution has been observed in others.20 21 22
In the present study, we examined whether the downstream distribution or a more upstream one, or a switch with age from the former to the latter, occurs in mice. We studied the origins of the intercostal arteries because these sites have been extensively studied a range of other species, because they are the only locations where age-related distributions paralleling those at human branches have been demonstrated in an animal model,23 24 and because there are large numbers in each aorta. We used apoE/LDLR double-knockout mice25 because their disease develops sufficiently quickly that it can be mapped in young animals. Furthermore, they do not need to be fed a cholesterol-enhanced diet (which can increase variability9 ), and they have a lipoprotein profile more human than that of the apoE single-knockout mouse.25
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Eleven males aged 9 to 20 weeks were used in the present study. To confirm their broad similarity to the animals used in previous studies, total plasma cholesterol levels were determined in 2 mice by using a commercial enzymatic kit (Boehringer-Mannheim) and averaged 534 mg/dL. This value lies in the middle of the range (430 to 620 mg/dL) obtained in previous studies of the double-knockout mouse25 or of the apoE single-knockout mouse5 6 9 11 25 (from which there is no significant difference25 ). Plasma cholesterol concentrations show no obvious changes with age.6 9 11
Surgery
Mice were immobilized with ether and were
then given 120 µg/g IP of pentobarbital (Sagatal, Rhone Merieux). The
abdomen and thorax were opened, and a needle was inserted into the left
ventricle so that the aorta could be flushed with saline at a pressure
of 100 mm Hg. A hole made in the right atrium allowed drainage of
the fluid. Perfusion was continued for 1 to 2 minutes, until this fluid
became clear. The aorta was dissected out, and adherent connective
tissue was removed under a microscope. The cleaned aorta was then
placed in formalin. (Fixation without pressure may have slightly
altered the in vivo geometry of the arterial branches but
could not have led to any confusion about relative disease frequencies
in upstream and downstream regions.)
Histology
The descending thoracic segment of the aorta was
processed by a modification of our previous
techniques.23 24 26
Briefly, it was immersed for 1 hour in 4% (vol/vol)
glutaraldehyde and 5% (vol/vol) formalin to form
highly autofluorescent
structures27 and then for 2
hours in a 1% (wt/vol) solution of oil red O in 60% (vol/vol)
triethyl phosphate to stain lipid. It was subsequently destained for 15
minutes and then transferred to PBS (0.15 mol/L, pH 7.4).
After the stubs of the intercostal arteries had been trimmed to within 0.5 to 1.0 mm of their origins, the segment was opened along its ventral surface and flattened between a microscope slide and a coverslip, with the luminal surface uppermost. It was then examined by epifluorescence microscopy (x4 objective and standard filters for fluorescein isothiocyanate, Zeiss). Emission from the lipid stain contrasts in color with the glutaraldehyde-stimulated autofluorescence of the normal wall and was recorded on color print film. This technique permits lipid deposits to be examined with microscopical resolution, and because epifluorescence is used, there is no influence from any fat remaining on the adventitial surface.
Mapping
Maps of lesion frequency were obtained for each mouse
by using our previous
methods,26 with
modifications to accommodate the smaller vessels. Briefly, a
transparent grid of 35x15 square elements (each with 50-µm length
before magnification) was placed over the photomicrograph of each
branch, and the presence or absence of staining was manually
recorded in every square. All mapping was conducted by 1 observer
(C.J.M.); intersession variability is not
significant.23 Grids were
combined to generate a map of lesion frequency for each mouse, and
these maps were also combined to obtain mean frequencies for the
various groups of mice described below. Such frequency-mapping
techniques, unlike the polar coordinate method, can include lesions
within the ostium, those not directly in contact with the ostial lip,
and those extending beyond the mapped
region.26 28
Statistical Analysis
Results are given as mean±SEM, and n indicates the
number of mice unless otherwise stated. Changes with respect to age
were assessed by ANOVA applied to regression, and comparisons between
groups of young and old mice were made by the Student unpaired
t test (1-tailed when examining
increases in disease severity with age). The
t statistic was also used for
testing the difference of ratios from
unity.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Disease Severity and Distribution in All
Mice
Disease was detected in all aortas but not at every
branch. To calculate a representative frequency, values
were averaged across the map for each mouse; these means were then
themselves averaged for all mice, giving a value of 15±4% (n=11). The
mean frequency for the 100 grid squares (10x10 array) centered on the
branch was also averaged for all mice. A 3-fold higher value (46±7%)
was obtained, indicating that disease was associated closely with the
branch.
The map for all mice is shown in
Figure 1A
. The disease is clearly centered on the branch,
with high frequencies in the ostium itself. Frequencies were also high
upstream, at the sides, and downstream of the ostium. Images of
branches with typical patterns of staining are shown in
Figure 1A
through 1D. Some of the disease appearing within
the ostia may in fact have developed on the walls of the intercostal
arteries (which could have been pushed up into the ostium when the
aorta was flattened on the microscope stage), and its density may have
been exaggerated because the vessels were not fixed at pressure;
however, it is clear from published photomicrographs of sections
through pressure-fixed
branches10 that intercostal
ostia in knockout mice do become almost completely blocked by disease
originating from the ostial margins.
|
To determine whether there was a higher frequency upstream or downstream of the branch, the mean frequency in the 100 grid squares (10x10 array) upstream of the branch center and the mean for the equivalent 100 squares downstream of the center were calculated for each mouse. The ratio of the upstream to downstream values, averaged for all mice, was 2.12±0.30 (n=11). This ratio was significantly different from unity (t=3.77, P<0.01), indicating that there was consistently more disease upstream of the branch. However, unlike the upstream pattern in human vessels, there was no sparing downstream of the branch. The frequency in the downstream region was at least as high as the mean for the whole map (22±6% downstream compared with 15±4% overall), even though it was less than half the frequency upstream.
Many branches showed a characteristic detail in the pattern
of staining in the upstream region: a crescentic or triangular region
of apparent sparing occurred immediately upstream from the ostium and
was surrounded by a line or larger patch of stain. An example is shown
in
Figure 2A
. This detail in the pattern of staining was not
visible on the map of average frequencies for all mice
(Figure 1A
) because it did not occur at every branch and
because its location was somewhat variable. However, it was clearly
visible in the maps for some individual mice (eg,
Figure 2B
).
|
Effect of Age on Disease Severity and
Distribution
To determine whether the pattern and severity of
disease changed with age, the analysis described above was
repeated for the 55 branches from the 5 mice aged <15 weeks (mean age
11.5 weeks) and for the 47 branches from the 6 mice aged >16 weeks
(mean age 18.0 weeks). The resulting maps are shown in
Figures 3A
and 3B
, respectively.
|
An increase in disease frequency with age is visible in the maps, as expected. This impression was confirmed quantitatively by the mean frequencies of 8±2% (n=5) for the young group and 21±5% (n=6) for the older group (t=2.12, P=0.031), by the means for the central 100 grid squares of 30±7% for the young group and 57±10% for the older group (t=2.08, P=0.033), and by the peak frequencies of 60% (young group) and 95% (older group).
Furthermore, when the mice were considered individually
rather than in 2 age groups, there was a trend for the mean disease
frequency to increase with age
(Figure 4A
), which approached statistical significance
(P=0.062 by ANOVA after
logarithmic transformation), and there was a stronger trend for the
frequency in the central 100 squares to increase with age
(Figure 4B
); the variation in this region was lower, and the
trend reached significance
(P=0.038 by ANOVA after
logarithmic transformation).
|
Inspection of the maps for the young and older groups did not reveal any obvious differences in distribution. To examine the distribution quantitatively, the ratio of the frequency for the 100 grid squares upstream of the branch to the equivalent downstream frequency was calculated. The values obtained were 2.30±0.39 for the young group and 1.97±0.46 for the older group; the difference was not significant (t=0.54, P=0.61).
The ratio was also examined in individual mice rather than
in the 2 groups, and this also failed to show an effect of age
(P=0.439 by ANOVA). Not only
was there no evidence for a switch from a downstream to an upstream
distribution with age, but if anything, there was a trend in the
opposite direction
(Figure 4C
). Only 1 outlier (an older mouse with an
anomalously low frequency of disease as well as an atypical
distribution) was markedly at variance with this trend; the tendency
for a more downstream pattern in older mice became significant
(P=0.008 by ANOVA) if the data
from this mouse were removed. However, the ratio remained >1 (ie,
there was more disease upstream) in all mice except for one 17-week-old
mouse.
The characteristic detail in the pattern of staining upstream of the ostium, described above, was seen in branches from the youngest and the oldest aortas and at intermediate ages.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the present study, we found no definite downstream, lateral, or upstream distribution around intercostal branch ostia of apoE/LDLR double-knockout mice; all 3 regions were affected. The frequency of lipid deposition was 2-fold higher in the upstream region than the downstream region, but it is our interpretation that this result alone does not indicate a pattern resembling those occurring in adult human arteries. There was no peak in frequencies lateral to the ostia, nor was there a streak emerging from the upstream lip of the branch. Most importantly, there was no consistent sparing downstream of the branch; although such sparing was seen at some branches, the mean frequency in the downstream region was higher than that for the map as a whole. The overall impression was of disease centered on and completely surrounding the branch, albeit with a bias toward the upstream location.
Only a relatively limited range of ages was studied, but this was as much as the model would permit. In the younger mice, there was little disease, whereas in the older mice, there was so much that a substantial percentage of the ostia could not be mapped. Within this range, we found no evidence of the switch with age from a downstream to a more upstream distribution seen in rabbit and human aortas. If anything, the reverse trend was apparent, although this effect became significant only with post hoc selection of data.
We are not aware of any previous studies to determine systematically the distribution of lipid deposits near arterial branches in mice. However, our observation of a lack of a clear downstream, lateral, or upstream pattern is consistent with impressions gained from illustrations in earlier reports. Thus, a sketch of the location of disease in apoE knockout mice9 shows lesions upstream of branches in the aortic arch but downstream of the origins of the celiac and superior mesenteric arteries; a photograph of disease in an apoE knockout mouse shows lesions completely surrounding 2 of the 3 affected intercostal ostia.10 One photograph4 of the aorta from an LDLR knockout mouse shows lipid deposition upstream and at the sides of branches, whereas another13 shows it upstream and downstream of the large abdominal branches. These observations in single-knockout mice seem to rule out the possibility that the lack of a distinctively upstream or downstream distribution in the present study arose because of the use of the double-knockout.
The conclusion that the distribution of lipid deposition around branches does not resemble the adult human pattern is supported by the previous observations that disease is prevalent in the aortic root and proximal coronary arteries of knockout mice. These are not common sites of disease in most mature human subjects, although, as noted by Ishibashi et al,8 they are affected in familial hypercholesterolemic patients.30 31 Further evidence for the disparity is the characteristic detail seen in the pattern of staining upstream of branches in the present study; this detail has not been reported for human vessels.
In summary, although we expected to find a downstream or an upstream distribution or a switch from a downstream to an upstream distribution with age, none of these was found. The distribution that was mapped did not resemble any previously described pattern of lipid staining. Although the results were obtained in the apoE/LDLR double-knockout mouse over a limited range of ages, they may be relevant to mouse models in general. Anecdotal evidence suggests that the same pattern occurs in apoE or LDLR single-knockout mice, and there are no obvious differences between studies that have used widely different ages. Thus, knockout mice seem inferior to some other species for investigating the pattern of human lipid deposition. In particular, they seem less useful for this purpose than rabbits, which show age-related changes in lesion distribution23 and type32 that parallel those seen in human aortas, and in which age-related alterations of NO-mediated permeability properties of the wall provide a plausible explanation.33 It is possible that the distribution of disease in mice may be different because the hemodynamic stresses are different. For example, the lower Reynolds numbers and higher Womersley numbers may lead to distinct inflow patterns into branches. Alternatively, the underlying properties of the wall or the disease process itself may differ. Until these issues are resolved, the present results suggest that inferences concerning human disease should be drawn with caution. Unless the difference in mechanical stresses can alone account for the discrepancy in distributions, the mouse would not be a useful species in which to investigate the roles of genes putatively involved in disease localization.
Two aspects of the distribution of disease in knockout mice merit further investigation. The first aspect is the possibility that different patterns occur around branches at different points along the aorta. Nakashima et al9 have indicated that disease occurs upstream of branches in the aortic arch but downstream of those in the abdominal aorta. The present finding of upstream and downstream disease at branches between the arch and abdomen fits this trend. Also consistent with this, we found a greater tendency for lesions to develop upstream of branches in the thoracic than in the abdominal aorta of mature rabbits.23 Hence, there could be a gradient of some critical localizing factor down the aorta.
The second aspect is that the distribution of lipid staining in the mouse resembles descriptions of the pattern of raised lesions around intercostal branches in aged human aortas.34 In such vessels, disease completely surrounds the ostium, giving the appearance of a volcano. It may be significant that the mouse lesions are fibroproliferative and lead rapidly to stenoses,5 6 9 10 11 13 35 unlike those of other models. The mouse lesions stain for lipid when observed en face, whereas advanced human disease does not, but this could reflect the much higher cholesterol levels in the mouse. There is long-standing uncertainty concerning whether fibroproliferative lesions have a different distribution and etiology from fatty streaks.34 36 If they do, knockout mice may provide a better model for the former.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received January 18, 2001; accepted April 3, 2001.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
B-like transcription factor activation in
response to an atherogenic diet in mice.
J Clin Invest. 1993;91:25722579.
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. J. Petrovan, C. D. Kaplan, R. A. Reisfeld, and L. K. Curtiss DNA Vaccination Against VEGF Receptor 2 Reduces Atherosclerosis in LDL Receptor-Deficient Mice Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., May 1, 2007; 27(5): 1095 - 1100. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Suo, D. E. Ferrara, D. Sorescu, R. E. Guldberg, W. R. Taylor, and D. P. Giddens Hemodynamic Shear Stresses in Mouse Aortas: Implications for Atherogenesis Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., February 1, 2007; 27(2): 346 - 351. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. E. Ferrara, D. Weiss, P. H. Carnell, R. P. Vito, D. Vega, X. Gao, S. Nie, and W. R. Taylor Quantitative 3D fluorescence technique for the analysis of en face preparations of arterial walls using quantum dot nanocrystals and two-photon excitation laser scanning microscopy Am J Physiol Regulatory Integrative Comp Physiol, January 1, 2006; 290(1): R114 - R123. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
ATVB Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 2001 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |