Original Contributions |
From the Robarts Research Institute, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario (R.A.H.); the Department of Biochemistry, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia (W.C.B.); the Department of Medical Genetics, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta (D.W.C.); and the Department of Medicine, St. Michael's Hospital, University of Toronto, Ontario (G.F.M., J.A.L., P.W.C.), Canada.
Correspondence to Dr Robert A. Hegele, Blackburn Cardiovascular Genetics Laboratory, Robarts Research Institute, 406-100 Perth Dr, London, Ontario, Canada N6A 5K8. E-mail robert.hegele{at}rri.on.ca
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: genetics lipoproteins LDL subclasses lipolysis lipoprotein lipase
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Most patients with HL deficiency due to HL mutations have been ascertained on the basis of dyslipidemia. However, among carriers of HL mutations associated with loss of function, such as R186H, S267F, L334F, and T383M, there are disparities in both the biochemical phenotype and the association with atherosclerosis susceptibility.14 15 16 17 For example, in a Canadian family, compound heterozygotes for HL S267F and T383M had (1) combined hyperlipidemia, (2) TG enrichment of LDL and HDL, (3) ß-migrating VLDL, (4) impaired chylomicron remnant metabolism, and (5) early coronary heart disease.14 However, the limited number of subjects in this family made it difficult to conclude whether simple heterozygotes had a discrete phenotype. In a Finnish family, compound heterozygotes for L334F and T383M did not have ß-migrating VLDL but did have TG enrichment of LDL and HDL.15 Also, Finnish heterozygotes for an HL allele that carried R186H and L334F appeared to have TG enrichment of LDL and HDL.16 Homozygosity for a splice-site mutation in HL intron I was associated with hypertriglyceridemia and coronary heart disease; however, there was no obvious biochemical phenotype among heterozygotes.17
The disparity among the results of studies of phenotype in heterozygotes for loss-of-function mutations in HL has many possible explanations. First, only a small number of heterozygotes have been identified, limiting the power for statistical analyses. Second, the variable impairment of in vitro HL function attributable to the different HL mutations may be reflected as clinical heterogeneity. Third, there could be underlying hyperlipidemias independent of any HL abnormality in the families studied. Such independent hyperlipidemias might have contributed to the initial ascertainment of the families and might produce a phenotype that is unrelated to, or at least modulates, the phenotype due to HL deficiency. Finally, heterozygosity for a loss-of-function mutation may not affect biochemical phenotypes in the presence of the other, functionally normal HL allele. It may be possible to resolve such disparities by studying larger kindreds with HL mutations.
Several subjects in the first kindred ever reported with a mutation in a plasma apolipoprotein, namely apo CII-T, were noted to have depressed postheparin HL activity.18 In particular, 5 of 8 extensively studied apo CII-T homozygotes had low but detectable HL activity. This finding suggested the possibility that these subjects were heterozygous for a loss-of-function mutation in HL. In a screening experiment, we identified the presence of the HL S267F mutation in this kindred and subsequently screened a large number of family members to identify several new heterozygous carriers of HL S267F to better characterize the biochemical phenotype of these subjects.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Biochemical and Genetic Determinations
Assays of plasma lipids and lipoproteins and electrophoretic
analysis of the apolipoproteins of chylomicrons and VLDL were
performed by using established procedures19 20 21
in each of the family members tested. DNA was extracted as
described.22 Screening for known mutations in
HL, namely -480T, V73M, R186H, N193S, S267F, L334F, and
T383M, was performed as described14 15 16 17 23 in 3
subjects from C2T who were known to be deficient in HL activity in
postheparin plasma. Genotypes of HL
S267F were determined by using polymerase chain reaction amplification
and digestion with HinfI as
described.14
Statistical Analyses
We wanted to test the hypothesis that within the nuclear
families, subjects who were heterozygotes for either mutation had
different biochemical phenotypes than did subjects within the
nuclear families who did not carry the mutations. Thus, biochemical
traits for heterozygotes for either HL S267F or apo CII-T
were compared with matched control subjects from these nuclear
families. Because of the small numbers of subjects and the nonnormal
distribution of the biochemical variables,
nonparametric analysis was carried out using the
Kruskal-Wallis
2 approximation test of
significance of the Wilcoxon rank sums.24
By convention, a value of P<0.05 was taken as the nominal
level of significance for a difference in the pairwise comparisons.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Composition of the Study Sample
The 84 adult subjects from the complex C2T kindred who had
sufficient plasma and cellular material available for all
analyses and who were not homozygous for apo CII-T could be
placed into 22 nuclear families. Each subject studied was between 4 and
7 generations removed from a common ancestral husband-wife pair. At
least 1 subject with HL S267F was found in 8 of the 22
nuclear families. At least 1 subject with apo CII-T was found in 17 of
the 22 nuclear families. Three of the nuclear families had compound
heterozygotes for HL S267F and apo CII-T. At least 1 subject
without either mutant allele was found in each of the nuclear
families in which simple heterozygotes had been found. Thus, there was
an adequate number of genotypically normal subjects from within each
nuclear family to serve as controls for simple heterozygotes in
pairwise analyses of biochemical traits.
Association of Genotype With Variation in Biochemical
Variables
Table 1
shows the results of
nonparametric statistical comparisons of the biochemical
traits of 11 adult family members who were heterozygous for
HL S267F and nuclear family control subjects. Notably, there
was no nominally significant difference among the genotypic classes in
mean plasma concentrations of total, VLDL, LDL, or HDL
cholesterol and no significant difference in plasma TGs.
Only the TG content of LDL was significantly different between
genotypic classes (P=0.002). The mean±SD for LDL TGs in 11
HL S267F subjects and 24 matched family controls were,
respectively, 39.0±5.9 and 30.8±15.2 mmol/L. In contrast, the
mean±SD for total plasma TGs in 11 HL S267F subjects and 24
matched family controls were, respectively, 145.6±62.4 and
195.4±351.7 mmol/L.
|
Table 2
shows the results of
nonparametric statistical comparisons of the biochemical
traits of 12 adult family members who were heterozygous for apo CII-T
and nuclear family control subjects. Notably, there was no nominally
significant difference among the genotypic classes in mean plasma
concentrations of total, VLDL, LDL, or HDL cholesterol. In
contrast to the HL S267F heterozygotes, both the TG content
of LDL and the concentration of total plasma TG were significantly
different in apo CII-T heterozygotes compared with control subjects
(P=0.009 and 0.005, respectively). The mean±SD for LDL TGs
in 12 apo CII-T subjects and 31 matched family controls were,
respectively, 43.7±20.8 and 29.3±10.5 mmol/L. In contrast to
simple heterozygotes for HL S267F, the mean±SD for total
plasma TGs in 12 apo CII-T subjects and family matched controls were,
respectively, 329.1±536.7 and 150.0±234.6 mmol/L. Pairwise
comparisons of 4 compound heterozygotes demonstrated no significant
differences in any biochemical trait compared with family matched
control subjects (data not shown).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The lipolytic process is mediated by endothelial cellbound lipoprotein lipase (LPL), for which apo CII is a cofactor, and by HL on the surface of the hepatic endothelium.3 Although it has greater affinity for the TG-rich lipoproteins, LPL has also been shown to be able to hydrolyze the TG component of LDL.25 26 It is thus possible that impairment of LPL activity due to defective apo CII-T might affect hydrolysis not only of TG-rich lipoproteins, and thus total plasma TG concentrations, but also the TG component of LDL. In contrast, HL has greater affinity in vitro for smaller-size IDL, LDL, and HDL particles than for TG-rich lipoproteins.8 27 28 HL in vitro can convert larger, TG-rich LDL into smaller LDL.27 28 Thus, the relative lack of affinity of HL for TG-rich lipoproteins, compared with LPL, might explain how a genetic mutation affecting HL activity, namely HL S267F, might affect LDL TGs but not total plasma TGs.
Both HL S267F and apo CII-T have abnormal functions,18 29 and each has previously been shown to contribute to abnormal lipoprotein phenotypes. For example, compound heterozygosity for HL S267F and T383M alleles produces elevated plasma concentrations of cholesterol and TGs, with TG enrichment of LDL and HDL, and the notable presence of ß-migrating VLDL.14 Also, homozygosity for apo CII-T produces hyperlipoproteinemia type I, with complete absence of LPL activity, hyperchylomicronemia, and pancreatitis.18 Furthermore, the presence of a single APOE E4 allele occurring in individuals with a single, mutant apo CII-T allele has been associated with higher plasma concentrations of cholesterol, TGs, and VLDL cholesterol when compared with relatives who carried neither or only 1 variant allele.21 The data from the current report suggest that although routine biochemical tests might have been adequate to detect the association of apo CII-T with elevated plasma TGs, only the more labor-intensive procedure of ultracentrifugation of plasma would have permitted detection of the more subtle finding of increased LDL TGs for both of these mutations.
Although it is possible that the phenotypic association with HL variation was due to linkage disequilibrium with another causative variant, it is unlikely, considering that the HL S267F mutation has a known functional impact.29 Heterozygotes for HL S267F have a 50% to 70% decrease in postheparin HL activity compared with normal control subjects,14 consistent with in vitro findings that HL S267F is associated with a complete absence of detectable activity and a virtual absence of secreted mass.29 Heterozygotes for other HL mutations that cause reduced HL mass and postheparin plasma HL activity, such as R186H and L334F, also appear to have TG-enriched LDL particles.
Although it is possible that the phenotypic association with the
APOC2 variation was due to linkage disequilibrium with
another causative variant, it is unlikely, considering that the apo
CII-T mutation has a known functional impact.18
Heterozygotes for apo CII-T have an
50% decrease in apo CII mass
and capacity to activate LPL.21 The
association of heterozygosity for apo CII-T with higher total TGs and
LDL TGs suggests that impairment of this pathway can affect lipoprotein
quantity and composition. The absence of associations of lipoprotein
phenotypes with compound heterozygosity for both mutations was
likely due to small numbers.
A possible pathophysiological role of TG-enriched LDL is not well defined. In the absence of a major lipolytic deficiency, LDL TG content is directly related to plasma TG concentration30 and to body mass.31 Also, LDL TGs increase on a fat-free, high-carbohydrate diet.32 Although the initial TG content of an LDL particle may affect its capacity for lipid exchange,33 it is not clear that this characteristic has any pathological consequence. Occasional reports have suggested that LDL TGs are better discriminators of myocardial infarction than is LDL cholesterol.34 Smaller, dense LDL particles are consistently related to atherosclerosis risk.35 36 37 However, LDL size and buoyancy are not related to particle TG content, despite higher total plasma TGs in subjects with a preponderance of small, dense LDL.38
In vivo studies indicate that the LDL TG content depends on HL activity. For example, immune inactivation of HL resulted in an increase in LDL TGs.39 In a study of young men, there was an inverse relationship between HL activity and the plasma level of LDL TGs.40 These findings are consistent with our observation that diminished HL activity resulting from the presence of HL S267F is associated with an increase in plasma LDL TGs. HL may influence LDL lipid composition by affecting the surface lipid component.41 Subjects who have a preponderance of small, dense LDL also have higher HL activity than do subjects with more buoyant LDL,38 although this would appear to be unrelated to LDL particle TG content.38
In summary, we found that plasma LDL TGs were significantly higher, by
40%, in both HL S267F and apo CII-T simple heterozygotes
than in relatives who had neither mutation. However, plasma LDL TGs
were not significantly higher in compound heterozygotes than in simple
heterozygotes. This suggests that the TG content of LDL is increased by
heterozygosity for at least 2 different mutations affecting the
lipolytic system, including simple heterozygosity for the catalytically
inactive HL S267F variant. Furthermore, the association of
TG-enriched LDLs with elevated total plasma TG concentrations in
heterozygotes for apo CII-T but not in heterozygotes for HL
S267F suggests that there are different reasons for TG enrichment from
the 2 different mutations. However, in spite of these associations, the
relationship, if any, between TG-enriched LDLs and pathological end
points remains unclear. The tenuous nature of such a relationship may
be a factor that has complicated the study of the association of HL
activity, lipoprotein metabolism, and
atherosclerosis.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received October 31, 1997; accepted February 17, 1998.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Phe and Thr383
Met: correlation between
hepatic lipase activity and phenotypic expression. J Lipid
Res. 1996;37:825834.[Abstract]
G mutation of intron I of the
hepatic lipase gene leads to alternative splicing resulting in enzyme
deficiency. J Lipid Res. 1996;37:12131223.[Abstract]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
R. A. Hegele, H. Cao, M. W. Huff, and C. M. Anderson LMNA R482Q Mutation in Partial Lipodystrophy Associated with Reduced Plasma Leptin Concentration J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab., September 1, 2000; 85(9): 3089 - 3093. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
R. A. HEGELE, H. CAO, S. B. HARRIS, B. ZINMAN, A. J. HANLEY, and C. M. ANDERSON Genetic variation in LMNA modulates plasma leptin and indices of obesity in aboriginal Canadians Physiol Genomics, June 29, 2000; 3(1): 39 - 44. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. A. Hegele, C. M. Anderson, J. Wang, D. C. Jones, and H. Cao Association Between Nuclear Lamin A/C R482Q Mutation and Partial Lipodystrophy with Hyperinsulinemia, Dyslipidemia, Hypertension, and Diabetes Genome Res., May 1, 2000; 10(5): 652 - 658. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
ATVB Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 1998 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |