Original Contributions |
From the Department of Internal Medicine, University Hospital Utrecht, Utrecht (H.T.W., D.W.E.); the Department of Cardiology, Oosterschelde Hospital Goes, Goes (J.E.R. van L., H.W.O.R. van L., A.-H.L., J.A.J. de B.); and the Julius Center for Patient-Oriented Research, University Hospital Utrecht, Utrecht (Y.T. van der S.), the Netherlands.
Correspondence to H.E. Westerveld, MD, University Hospital Utrecht, G02.228 Heidelberglaan 100, 3584 CX Utrecht, PO Box 85.500, 3508 GA Utrecht, Netherlands. E-mail h.e.westerveld{at}digd.azu.nl
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: apolipoprotein B coronary artery disease coronary angiography women
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Data on apoB as a risk indicator for CAD in women are limited.1 Although CAD is the major cause of death in women, the absolute numbers of clinical manifestations of CAD are low.3 4 5 6 Thus, long-term studies in large numbers of women are required to evaluate the impact of risk factors on CAD. Studies with surrogate end points, such as coronary angiograms, are useful.
ApoB has been associated with angiographically determined CAD in a small group of Asiatic women7 and in women with premature (<60 years) CAD.8 ApoB was also related to CAD in a larger angiography study that included women on lipid-lowering medication and women for whom nonfasting lipid measurements were available.9 Fasting plasma samples are essential for comparison between different lipid parameters because TG concentrations increase10 11 12 and HDL-chol concentrations decrease in the postprandial state in both men10 and women.11 13 In the current angiography study in a large group of women, only fasting plasma samples were used for determination of lipids and apolipoproteins. Angiographies were performed in a community-referral hospital. No age or lipid selection criteria were used in an attempt to obtain a representative sample of women from the general population referred for angiography. We investigated whether apoB was an independent risk factor for CAD and whether apoB was superior to chol, LDL-chol, HDL-chol, TG, or apoA-I in discriminating between CAD+ and CAD- women. Frequency distributions of age, lipids, and apolipoproteins in CAD+ and CAD- women were also obtained.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Study Population
The study population consisted of women who were undergoing
their first coronary angiography between January 1992 and
January 1997. The indications for angiography were suspicion of CAD or
preoperative screening for CAD in subjects with valvular
disease. Women undergoing elective angiographies were included to avoid
the influence of stress situations, such as a myocardial infarction, on
plasma lipids. Women using lipid-lowering medication were excluded from
analysis. Plasma concentrations of chol, TGs, HDL-chol,
LDL-chol, apoA-I, and apoB were determined after an overnight fast
during the week preceding the angiography.
Angiography
Coronary angiographies were performed according to the
standard Judkins technique.14 Women were
classified as CAD+ if 1 or more coronary arteries had a
stenosis >60% on visual examination. The other women were
classified as CAD-.
Lipids and Apolipoproteins
Chol and TG concentrations were measured enzymatically (Vitros
analyzer, Johnson & Johnson). HDL-chol fractions were prepared
by precipitation from plasma of the apoB-containing lipoproteins with
the use of dextran sulfate and
MgCl2.10 Plasma LDL-chol
was calculated by using the Friedewald formula (total
chol-[HDL-chol]-[0.45xTG]). ApoA-I and apoB were measured by
immunonephelometry on a Beckman array protein system. Beckman reagents,
calibrators, and standards were used. From June 1995 onward, the
reference values for apoB were changed as a result of international
standardization according to IFCC/WHO standards (SP307). The assigned
values according to IFCC/WHO standards for apoB after June 1995 were
identical to those before June 1995 multiplied by 0.82. In the current
study the old values were converted to new values. ApoA-I reference
values, based on SP101, did not change.
Clinical and Lifestyle Characteristics
Questionnaires were sent to the participants to retrospectively
obtain self-reported information about clinical and lifestyle
characteristics during the year preceding coronary angiography.
Height and weight were recorded. Women were classified as
never-smokers, past smokers, or current smokers. Diabetes was diagnosed
as non insulin-dependent if the age of onset was >30 years and the
first treatment was with diet modification or oral hypoglycemic
medication. Diabetes was diagnosed as insulin dependent if the age of
onset was <20 years and the first treatment was with insulin. The
diagnosis of diabetes with an onset between 20 and 30 years of age was
obtained from the patient's records. Women were diagnosed as
hypertensive if a physician had told them they had hypertension or if
they were using antihypertensive medication. Family history was
considered positive if at least 1 of the parents, siblings, or children
had manifestations of cardiovascular disease before the
age of 60 years. Ages at menarche and, if appropriate, at menopause
(surgical or natural) were recorded. Finally, the premenopausal use
of oral contraceptives and the postmenopausal use of HRT in any form
were recorded.
Statistics
Logistic regression was used to analyze the influence of
continuous and dichotomous variables on the presence of CAD (the
dependent variable). ANCOVA with age as a covariate was used to
analyze the effect of lipid and apolipoprotein values on 1-,
2-, or 3-vessel disease. Student's t tests for independent
samples were used to analyze differences in apoB concentrations
between CAD- and CAD+ groups for each quartile of the other lipid or
apolipoprotein variable. Because the distribution of TG values was
skewed, all TG calculations were performed after logarithmic
transformation. Values are expressed as mean±SD. Two-tailed
P values <0.05 were considered significant. The
SPSS (SPSS) software program was used.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Angiography
The CAD- group consisted of 129 women. The indications for
angiography in the CAD- group were suspicion of CAD (81%) or
preoperative screening for CAD in valvular disease (19%). All
CAD- women only had vascular wall irregularities and stenosis
<10%. The CAD+ group consisted of 160 women, and the indications for
angiography in the CAD+ group were suspicion of CAD (98%) or
preoperative screening for CAD in valvular disease (2%). The
CAD+ group was further divided into 1-vessel (n=78), 2-vessel (n=41),
and 3-vessel (n=32) disease groups. Nine women had a stenosis
in the left main coronary artery.
Clinical and Lifestyle Characteristics
CAD+ women were significantly older than CAD- women.
Noninsulin-dependent diabetes mellitus was present in 24 women
and insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus in 1 CAD+ woman. Both forms of
diabetes were pooled for analysis (Table 1
). Diabetes, smoking, and hypertension
were significantly associated with CAD+ after correction for age. The
body mass index was not different between CAD- (25.94±4.33
kg/m2) and CAD+ (26.24±4.04
kg/m2) women. Premature CAD, diagnosed as disease
onset at <60 years of age, was present in 26.3% of CAD+ women. In
the normolipidemic subgroup, defined as chol <6.5 mmol/L and TG
<2.3 mmol/L, CAD was associated with age (P=0.008),
but after correction for age, smoking was the only nonlipid risk factor
that was significantly associated with CAD (P=0.03).
|
Hormonal Status
The majority of the women (88.5%) were postmenopausal. The age at
menopause was 49.17±4.3 years for women with a natural menopause
(n=168) and 41.65±7.3 years for women with surgical menopause (n=23)
(Table 1
). After correction for age, postmenopausal status (natural or
surgical) was no longer a predictor of CAD. Ever-use of HRT was
associated with reduced CAD (P=0.012), but after correction
for age, this was no longer significant (P=0.07). Only
12.4% of the postmenopausal women had ever used HRT in any form, and
the mean duration of HRT was 3.2±4.0 years (range, 0.2 to 16). Twenty
percent of the postmenopausal women had undergone hysterectomy.
Lipids and Apolipoproteins
Plasma chol concentrations in 5-year age categories of the entire
study group were in the same range as chol concentrations in Dutch
women from the general population (Tables 2
, 3
, and 4
and Figure 1
).15 16 Fasting
plasma concentrations of chol, LDL-chol, TGs, and apoB were
significantly higher and HDL-chol was significantly lower in CAD+ women
than in CAD- women (Table 2
), and this association remained so after
correction for age. The extent of CAD, expressed as the number of
stenotic coronary arteries, was associated with chol,
LDL-chol, apoB, and age. After correction for age, apoB remained the
most significant parameter (Table 3
). In a normolipidemic
subgroup (chol
6.5 mmol/L and TGs
2.3 mmol/L), apoB and
LDL-chol were the only parameters associated with CAD after
correction for age (Table 4
).
|
|
|
|
Each lipid parameter was an independent risk factor for CAD
(logistic regression). After correction for confounders in clinical and
lifestyle characteristics, the odds ratios for CAD were 11.1 for apoB
(g/L), 1.5 for chol (mmol/L), 1.66 for LDL-chol (mmol/L), 0.68 for
HDL-chol (mmol/L), and 5.1 for log TGs (log scale). Owing to
differences in the units of measure, odds ratios cannot be directly
compared. Therefore, lipid and apolipoprotein parameters
were divided into quartiles. In any quartile of apoB, no significant
differences between CAD- and CAD+ women were observed for chol,
LDL-chol, HDL-chol, or TG. In contrast, apoB was significantly higher
in CAD+ than in CAD- women in the lowest quartiles of chol, LDL-chol,
and log TG, and there was a trend toward higher apoB levels in CAD+
versus CAD- in the highest HDL-chol quartile (Figure 1
). In addition,
apoB was significantly higher in CAD+ versus CAD- in the second and
fourth log TG quartiles, in the fourth LDL-chol quartile, in the fourth
chol quartile, and in the second HDL-chol quartile (data not
shown).
Frequency distributions of chol and apoB in CAD+ and CAD- women are
shown in Figures 2
and 3
. Of the CAD+ women, 68.7% had an
elevated apoB concentration (>1.3 g/L). Of the CAD- women, 55.8% had
a normal apoB concentration (
1.3 g/L). In the CAD+ group, chol
concentration exceeded 6.5 mmol/l in 65%, an LDL-chol
concentration >3.5 mmol/L was present in 90%, and LDL-chol
concentrations were >2.5 mmol/L in 99% of the women. ApoB
(P=0.0003), chol (P<0.001), and LDL-chol
(P=0.0003) showed a linear increase with age expressed in
5-year intervals.
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The role of apoB as an important risk factor is biologically plausible,18 19 since plasma apoB concentrations reflect the number of atherogenic lipoprotein particles.20 The atherogenic lipoproteins are LDL, containing predominantly chol, VLDL remnants (IDL), and chylomicron remnants, which contain both chol and TGs. LDL and remnant particles each contain 1 molecule of apoB as the structural protein, whereas the amount of chol and TGs per particle varies, and with it, the atherogenicity of the particle. Large, TG-rich VLDL particles are not considered atherogenic,21 whereas smaller remnants of TG-rich lipoprotein particles are atherogenic.22 Small, dense LDL particles are more atherogenic than are LDL particles of normal composition.23 Increased small, dense LDL concentrations are reflected by a more pronounced elevation of LDL apoB than of LDL-chol, and this trend is often accompanied by elevated plasma TG concentrations. Chol is a constituent of both atherogenic, apoB-containing lipoproteins and antiatherogenic, apoA-containing lipoproteins. This heterogeneity of lipoprotein particle composition can explain the superiority of apoB over chol and TG as a CAD risk factor.
Prospective population-based studies have designated HDL-chol as the most powerful lipid risk factor in women,4 5 24 25 26 but in these studies apoB was not determined. Cross-sectional analysis of the Framingham Offspring population showed that apoB concentrations were related to CAD in women.27 Data on apoB as a risk factor for CAD in the general population will also become available from a prospective, population-based observational study, including a large number of US women.28
Although apoB was the best discriminant between CAD- and CAD+ in the current study, there was still considerable overlap in apoB between CAD- and CAD+. Other studies have shown that the predictive power of apoB can be increased by separation of the plasma into different apoB-containing lipoprotein fractions. The fasting remnant, or IDL fraction, was superior to the LDL fraction in predicting the presence8 or severity29 of CAD in women with premature CAD. Postprandial chylomicron remnant concentrations were higher in CAD+ than in CAD- women while LDL apoB was similar.12 IDL-chol was also related to the progression of CAD in a combined group of men and women (n=63) with premature CAD,30 and IDL mass was related to the progression of carotid artery intima-media thickness in a study in men and women (n=24) combined.31 Early data from Framingham showed that in women, and in particular in postmenopausal women, remnant chol was related to CAD.32 Thus, in women, parameters for remnant particles are potentially better CAD risk indicators than is plasma apoB.
A limitation of the current study is the selection of women for angiography. Although only women who were undergoing their first angiography were included and women on lipid-lowering medication were excluded, the women who were suspected of having CAD could have changed their lifestyle. The CAD- women, who were referred for angiography because of suspected CAD, were likely to have more risk factors compared with CAD- women from the general population. These considerations would more likely underestimate than overestimate the strength of apoB as a risk factor. Still, the findings from the current study can be applied to women who are referred for angiography but cannot be extrapolated directly to the general population.
Currently, guidelines for CAD prevention are focussed on LDL-chol,
although in women, LDL-chol is not a very powerful CAD risk
factor.4 For secondary prevention, the target
level for LDL-chol is
2.6 mmol/L, and lipid-lowering therapy
should be initiated if LDL-chol is
3.4
mmol/L.33 34 In the current study, 99% of CAD+
women had an LDL-chol concentration >2.6 mmol/L. Ninety percent
of CAD+ women had an LDL-chol concentration
3.4 mmol/L, and
therefore, had an indication for lipid-lowering interventions. A
generally accepted apoB target level for prevention of
cardiovascular disease may be defined in the
future.
Hormonal Status
CAD is a disease of postmenopausal
women.6 35 In the current study 95% of the CAD+
women were postmenopausal. Estrogen deficiency has been reported to be
an independent risk factor for CAD assessed by
angiography.36 In the current study, menopause
was no longer a CAD risk factor after correction for age. This was
probably due to the relatively small number of premenopausal women.
Therefore, another measure of exposure to endogenous
estrogens was used: the age at menopause. Recently it has been reported
that the age at menopause is inversely associated with
cardiovascular mortality.37 This
association was not found in the Nurses' Health
Study,38 in which the population was rather
young. In the current study the age at menopause was not associated
with CAD after correction for age. These findings suggest that age is a
more important factor than endogenous estrogens. Another
explanation could be that the current study group is different from the
general population. In addition, endogenous estrogens are
potentially related to CAD through mechanisms that are not detectable
on angiography, such as vascular wall
reactivity.39 40 41 42 This would imply that
angiography studies are not an appropriate tool to evaluate the effect
of estrogens. Nevertheless, the effect of HRT on angiographically
defined CAD has repeatedly been
demonstrated43 44 45 46 and even linked to
survival.17 In the current study, few women ever
used HRT, and the mean duration of HRT was short.
Nonlipid Risk Factors
Smoking emerged as a stronger risk factor than hypertension and
diabetes. This also applied to the normolipidemic subgroup of women.
Cessation of smoking has been reported to reduce CAD risk by 50% to
80% in observational studies.47
In conclusion, in this community-based angiography study in women, plasma concentrations of apoB, reflecting the number of atherogenic lipoproteins, was the best lipoprotein or lipid discriminant between CAD- and CAD+. The majority of CAD+ women had an LDL >2.5 mmol/L, the target level for secondary prevention. The majority of the CAD+ women were also postmenopausal, and HRT has been associated with protection against CAD.48 It remains to be determined which intervention, lipid lowering per se, HRT (also known to reduce apoB49 50 51 ), or a combination of both will be the best strategy.
| Selected Abbreviations and Acronyms |
|---|
|
|
| Appendix 1 |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received October 6, 1997; accepted January 28, 1998.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. M. Ballantyne, J. S. Raichlen, and V. A. Cain Statin Therapy Alters the Relationship Between Apolipoprotein B and Low-Density Lipoprotein Cholesterol and Non-High-Density Lipoprotein Cholesterol Targets in High-Risk Patients: The MERCURY II (Measuring Effective Reductions in Cholesterol Using Rosuvastatin therapY II) Trial J. Am. Coll. Cardiol., August 19, 2008; 52(8): 626 - 632. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Meisinger, H. Loewel, W. Mraz, and W. Koenig Prognostic value of apolipoprotein B and A-I in the prediction of myocardial infarction in middle-aged men and women: results from the MONICA/KORA Augsburg cohort study Eur. Heart J., February 1, 2005; 26(3): 271 - 278. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Frohlich and M. Dobiasova Fractional Esterification Rate of Cholesterol and Ratio of Triglycerides to HDL-Cholesterol Are Powerful Predictors of Positive Findings on Coronary Angiography Clin. Chem., November 1, 2003; 49(11): 1873 - 1880. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. J. Gibbons, J. Abrams, K. Chatterjee, J. Daley, P. C. Deedwania, J. S. Douglas, T. B. Ferguson Jr, S. D. Fihn, T. D. Fraker Jr, J. M. Gardin, et al. ACC/AHA 2002 Guideline Update for the Management of Patients With Chronic Stable Angina--Summary Article: A Report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines (Committee on the Management of Patients With Chronic Stable Angina) Circulation, January 7, 2003; 107(1): 149 - 158. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Committee Members, R. J. Gibbons, J. Abrams, K. Chatterjee, J. Daley, P. C. Deedwania, J. S. Douglas, T. B. Ferguson Jr, S. D. Fihn, T. D. Fraker Jr, et al. ACC/AHA 2002 guideline update for the management of patients with chronic stable angina--summary article: a report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on practice guidelines (Committee on the Management of Patients With Chronic Stable Angina) J. Am. Coll. Cardiol., January 1, 2003; 41(1): 159 - 168. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
References Circulation, December 17, 2002; 106(25): 3373 - 3421. [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
J. E Roeters van Lennep, H.T. Westerveld, D.W. Erkelens, and E. E van der Wall Risk factors for coronary heart disease: implications of gender Cardiovasc Res, February 15, 2002; 53(3): 538 - 549. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. T.P. Keulen, M. Kruijshoop, N. C. Schaper, A. P.G. Hoeks, and T. W.A. de Bruin Increased Intima-Media Thickness in Familial Combined Hyperlipidemia Associated With Apolipoprotein B Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., February 1, 2002; 22(2): 283 - 288. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. E. R. van Lennep, H. T. Westerveld, H. W. O. R. van Lennep, A. H. Zwinderman, D. W. Erkelens, and E. E. van der Wall Apolipoprotein Concentrations During Treatment and Recurrent Coronary Artery Disease Events Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., November 1, 2000; 20(11): 2408 - 2413. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. M. Wagner, J. L. Sanchez-Quesada, A. Perez, M. Rigla, M. Cortes, F. Blanco-Vaca, and J. Ordonez-Llanos Inaccuracy of Calculated LDL-Cholesterol in Type 2 Diabetes: Consequences for Patient Risk Classification and Therapeutic Decisions Clin. Chem., November 1, 2000; 46(11): 1830 - 1832. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J.E Roeters van Lennep, A.H Zwinderman, H.W.O Roeters van Lennep, H.E Westerveld, H.W.M Plokker, A.A Voors, A.V.G Bruschke, and E.E van der Wall Gender differences in diagnosis and treatment of coronary artery disease from 1981 to 1997. No evidence for the Yentl syndrome Eur. Heart J., June 1, 2000; 21(11): 911 - 918. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. J. Moss, R. E. Goldstein, V. J. Marder, C. E. Sparks, D. Oakes, H. Greenberg, H. J. Weiss, W. Zareba, M. W. Brown, C.-S. Liang, et al. Thrombogenic Factors and Recurrent Coronary Events Circulation, May 18, 1999; 99(19): 2517 - 2522. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||