Articles |
Arg) Mutation Affects Lecithin
From the Department of Medicine, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland (H.E.M., H.G., T.A.M, K.K); the Department of Biochemistry, National Public Health Institute, Helsinki, Finland (M.J., S.E.); and the Department of Cardiology, Central Hospital of Hämeenlinna, Finland (A.P.).
Correspondence to Helena E. Miettinen, MD, Department of Medicine, University of Helsinki, Meilahti Hospital, Haartmaninkatu 4, 00290 Helsinki, Finland. E-mail Helena.Miettinen{at}helsinki.fi
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Arg mutation (apoA-IFin) results in dominantly
inherited hypoalphalipoproteinemia. In the present study we
investigated the effect of the apoA-IFin mutation on
lipoprotein profile, apoA-I kinetics, lecithin:cholesterol
acyltransferase (LCAT) activation, and cholesterol efflux
in vitro. Carriers (n=9) of the apoA-IFin mutation
exhibited several lipoprotein abnormalities. The serum HDL
cholesterol level was diminished to 20% of normal, and
nondenaturing gradient gel electrophoresis of HDL showed disappearance
of particles at the 9.0- to 12-nm size range (HDL2-type)
and the presence of small 7.8- to 8.9-nm (mostly HDL3-type)
particles only. HDL3-type particles from both the mutation
carriers and nonaffected family members were similarly converted to
large, HDL2-type particles by phospholipid transfer protein
in vitro. Studies on apoA-I kinetics in four affected subjects favored
accelerated catabolism of apoA-I. Experiments with reconstituted
proteoliposomes showed that the capacity of apoA-IFin
protein to activate LCAT was reduced to 40% of that of the
wild-type apoA-I. The impact of the apoA-IFin protein on
cholesterol efflux was examined in vitro using
[3H]cholesterol-loaded human fibroblasts and
three different cholesterol acceptors: (1) total HDL, (2)
total apoA-I combined with phospholipid, and (3) apoA-I isoform
(apoA-IFin or wild-type apoA-I isoform 1) combined with
phospholipid. ApoA-IFin did not impair phospholipid binding
or cholesterol efflux from fibroblasts to any of the
acceptors used. Only one of the nine apoA-IFin carriers
appears to have evidence of clinically manifested
atherosclerosis. In conclusion, although the
apoA-IFin mutation does not alter the properties of apoA-I
involved in promotion of cholesterol efflux, its ability to
activate LCAT in vitro is defective. In vivo,
apoA-IFin was found to be associated with several
lipoprotein composition rearrangements and increased catabolism of
apoA-I.
Key Words: reverse cholesterol transport HDL apolipoprotein A-I kinetics coronary artery disease mutation
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Human genetic HDL deficiency syndromes11 associated with extremely low serum HDL-C levels provide a unique opportunity to further investigate the in vivo role of HDL and apoA-I in protection against premature CAD. Genetic factors influencing structural or functional properties of apoA-I, LCAT, and thereby HDL could have an impact on RCT and thus influence the liability for CAD. However, although there are several inherited genetic disorders in which HDL-C and apoA-I levels are severely reduced, it is very seldom that they seem to be associated with increased risk of premature atherosclerosis.12
Although several mutations in the apoA-I gene have been
identified, 12 only a few of them cause extreme
forms of hypoalphalipoproteinemia.1324
Typically the phenotype is inherited in a codominant fashion:
affected subjects are homozygous for the mutation, and heterozygous
carriers have normal or approximately half normal HDL-C and apoA-I
concentrations. However, there are a few reports on specific apoA-I
gene mutations that have a dominant impact on the phenotypic expression
of HDL-C levels.16,17,2426
ApoA-IMilano, the first apolipoprotein variant
ever discovered, substitutes cysteine for arginine at the residue 173
of apoA-I, thus providing the mutant protein with the capability to
form dimers. Carriers of the mutation have reduced serum HDL-C and
apoA-I levels (33% and 60% of normal, respectively) and slight
hypertriglyceridemia, but they do not seem
to be at risk for premature CAD.27
ApoA-ISeattle, a de novo mutation detected in one
individual only, deletes amino acids 145 to 160 of the apoA-I protein
and diminishes HDL-C and apoA-I concentration below 15% of the
normal.17 We have previously described the
apoA-IFin (Leu 159
Arg) mutation causing
dominantly inherited hypoalphalipoproteinemia in a large kindred from
Finland.16 ApoA-IFin exerts
an even more profound effect on serum HDL-C and apoA-I levels than
A-IMilano, and heterozygous carriers of
apoA-IFin have HDL-C and apoA-I levels reduced to
20% and 25% of that of the nonaffected family members.
The present study was undertaken to further enlighten the structure-function relationships of apoA-I by examining the effect of apoA-IFin on overall lipoprotein profile, HDL particle size and composition, apoA-I kinetics, and LCAT activation. To gain more insight into the possible atherogenicity/antiatherogenicity of apoA-IFin, we extended our previous pedigree analysis16 and examined the impact of apoA-IFin on cholesterol efflux in vitro.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Measurement of Serum Lipids and Lipoproteins
Total cholesterol, free cholesterol,
triglycerides, and phospholipids were determined
enzymatically using commercial kits (Hoffmann-La Roche,
Boehringer Mannheim, and Wako Chemicals GmbH). Apolipoproteins
apoA-I, apoA-II, and apoB were measured with immunochemical assays
(Orion Diagnostica). Serum lipoproteins were separated by
ultracentrifugation into density
classes.28 HDL (from all family members) and LDL
fractions (from four affected and two nonaffected members) were further
divided into subfractions according to their densities by
ultracentrifugation; HDL into
HDL2 and HDL3 fractions
(d=1.063 to 1.125 g/mL and d=1.125 to 1.21 g/mL,
respectively) and LDL into light, dense, and ultra-dense LDL fractions
(d=1.019 to 1.036, 1.037 to 1.055, and 1.056 to 1.063 g/mL,
respectively).29 The separated lipoprotein
fractions were not corrected for recovery.
ApoA-IFin Genotyping
Genotyping of the new family members was performed by PCR
amplification of exon 4 of the apoA-I gene, followed by digestion of
the amplification products with the restriction enzyme
Fsp I as previously described.16 In
short, PCR was performed using primers 5'-AAGGTGCAGCCCTACCTG-3' and
5'-TTTATTCTGAGCACCGGGAA-3' and 30 amplification cycles at 95, 58, and
72°C for 1 minute each. The PCR product, 487 bp in size, was
digested with the restriction enzyme Fsp I (New England
Biolabs) and run on a 2.5% agarose gel. The T-to-G base substitution
destroys an existing Fsp I cutting site, resulting in an
amplification product 487 bp in size, while the normal allele
produces two fragments (294 and 193 bp) on digestion with
Fsp I.
HDL Particle Analysis
Fresh HDL fractions (5 µg of protein/well), separated by
ultracentrifugation from 7 affected and 16 unaffected
subjects, were run on self-casted nondenaturing polyacrylamide
gradient gels (4% to 22%) using a Mini-Protean II Cell
electrophoresis apparatus (Bio-Rad). Gels were casted using
a model 385 gradient former (Pharmacia) and a model EP-1 Econo Pump
(Pharmacia). A control HDL sample (stored in aliquots at -70°C) was
included in each electrophoresis. Commercial protein standards
(Pharmacia) were run in three lanes of the gels (in the center and in
both sides) to ensure calibration of particle sizes. The
electrophoresis running buffer (pH 8.4) consisted of 90
mmol/L Tris base, 80 mmol/L boric acid, 3
mmol/L EDTA and 3 mmol/L NaN3.
Before loading, HDL samples were diluted with loading buffer containing
40% sucrose and 0.05% bromphenol blue. Electrophoresis of the samples
was carried out at +4°C for 10 minutes with 40 V and continued for 4
hours with a constant voltage of 200 V. Proteins were then detected
with Coomassie brilliant blue G-250 (Bio-Rad) and destained with 5%
acetic acid. Gels were scanned and analyzed with the Bio Image
system (Millipore Co), and particle sizes were determined using
commercial protein standards (Pharmacia).
Measurement of CETP and PLTP Activity and HDL Conversion
Experiments
CETP activity was measured according to Groener et
al30 from two affected and two nonaffected family
members. Individual values were calculated as the CETP activity
measured from the sample divided by the activity of the internal
control and expressed as arbitrary units. PLTP was purified and assayed
as described previously.31 Purified PLTP
preparations were free of CETP, LCAT, and hepatic lipase and gave a
single band of 78 to 80 kDa when analyzed by SDS-PAGE.
Proteoliposomes for PLTP assays were prepared using 10 µmol of
egg PC, 1 µCi of [14C]dipalmitoyl
phosphatidylcholine, and 20 nmol of butylated hydroxytoluene. PLTP
assays were carried out in a volume of 400 µL containing
HDL3 (250 µg of protein), 150 nmol of
[14C]PC-labeled liposomes, plasma sample (4
µL of plasma/incubation, plasma first diluted 1:10 in TBS) and TBS,
pH 7.4.
The capability of PLTP to convert HDL3-type particles to large and small particles was examined by incubating native HDL3 or total HDLFin (250 µg of protein/incubation) in the absence and presence of PLTP (500 nmol/h/incubation, corresponding to approximately 0.6 µg of total protein) for 24 hours at +37°C as previously described.31 Incubations were carried out in a volume of 0.4 mL using a buffer containing 10 mmol/L Tris-HCl, pH 7.4, 150 mmol/L NaCl and 1 mmol/L EDTA (TBS). After incubations, the tubes were placed on ice, and the particle sizes were analyzed as described above.
Kinetic Studies
Kinetic studies were performed as previously
described.32 In brief, autologous apoA-I was
isolated from total HDL with guanidine hydrochloride incubation and
iodinated with 125I by a modification
of the iodine monochloride method.33 The total
amount of radioactivity per injected 125I-apoA-I
did not exceed 20 µCi. After the injection, blood samples were
collected and counted for 14 days. The die-away curves for the tracer
were constructed, and FCR was determined from these data using a
two-pool model.34 Transport rate was determined
by multiplying FCR by the respective pool size (calculated using serum
apoA-I values) of the tracer. Plasma volume was calculated as 4.5% of
body weight.
Isolation of ApoA-IFin
Plasma of a heterozygous carrier of the
apoA-IFin mutation was used as a source to
isolate the apoA-IFin protein. HDL was isolated
from plasma (400 mL, obtained by plasmapheresis) of both an affected
family member and a normal control subject by a series of
ultracentrifugations.28 ApoA-I
was purified from HDL using guanidine hydrochloride as described
previously,35 dialyzed against 5
mmol/L NH4HCO3, and
lyophilized. Lyophilized apoA-I samples (10 mg) were dissolved in 1 mL
of a buffer containing 0.01 mol/L Tris-HCl (pH 7.4) and 1%
decylsulfate. Separation of the apoA-IFin from
its normal apoA-I counterpart and control apoA-I from its normally
occurring second isoform was carried out by preparative IEF.
Preparative IEF gels were made as previously
described36 with the separating gradient covering
the pH range 4 to 6.5. After overnight electrophoresis, the gels were
covered with H2O, and the separated protein bands
were visualized under white light. Protein bands were cut from the
gels, followed by elution of proteins from gel slices with 4
mol/L guanidine hydrochloride. Protein preparations were
dialyzed against 5 mmol/L
NH4HCO3 for 16 hours,
lyophilized, and resolubilized into phosphate-buffered saline. Protein
concentrations were determined as described above, and aliquots were
stored at -20°C until use. Analytical IEF was used to confirm the
authenticity of the appropriate isoforms.
LCAT Activity Assay
LCAT was isolated from fresh human plasma using a method
described earlier37 with the following
modifications38,39: the anion exchanger Mono Q HR
5/5 (Pharmacia) was used instead of DEAE-Sephadex A-50, and the final
purification step was hydroxyl apatite chromatography
on Bio-Gel HTP (Bio Rad). The purified LCAT preparation exhibited a
single band on SDS-PAGE with an apparent molecular mass of 68 kDa and
was free of CETP, PLTP, and hepatic lipase. LCAT preparations were
stored at +4°C in TBS buffer until use.
ApoA-I-egg PC-[1,2-3H]cholesterol proteoliposomes were prepared by the cholate dialysis method as described.40 Four different apoA-I preparations were used: Control apoA-I (a gift from Swiss Red Cross, Central Laboratory, Switzerland), total apoA-I from an apoA-IFin carrier, wild-type apoA-I isoform isolated by IEF, or apoA-IFin isoform isolated by IEF. Egg PC and [3H]cholesterol in organic solvent were mixed, and organic solvents were evaporated under nitrogen followed by 30 minutes of lyophilization. The dried lipids were resolubilized by vortexing in TBS. ApoA-I and sodium cholate (final concentration 55 mmol/L) were then added, and the mixture was vortexed for 1 minute and incubated at +25°C for 30 minutes. Sodium cholate was then removed by dialyzing against TBS for 72 hours. Molar ratios of proteoliposome components were determined by measuring cholesterol and phospholipids by enzymatic methods and apoA-I by immunoturbidometry. Analysis of substrate compositions showed that all four proteoliposome preparations consisted of equal molar ratios of apoA-I, PC, and cholesterol (0.74±0.016, 262±6.74, and 8.9±0.29, mean±SE, respectively). All proteoliposomes were of similar size when evaluated with gel filtration in a Superose 6HR column, and the recoveries from the column were about 90%. Proteoliposomes were stored at +4°C under nitrogen and were used within 2 weeks.
LCAT activity was measured as described earlier38 using the freshly prepared proteoliposomes. In brief, the assay mixture consisted of 250 µL of assay buffer (TBS), 125 µL of 2% bovine serum albumin and 50 µL of egg PC-cholesterol-apoA-I proteoliposome substrate (corresponding to 11 µg of apoA-I/assay). The mixture was preincubated for 20 minutes at +37°C, after which 25 µL of 0.1 mol/L 2-mercaptoethanol and 25 to 50 µL of purified LCAT enzyme were added. The mixture was vortexed and incubated at +37°C for 30 minutes, and the reaction was stopped by adding 8 mL of chloroform-methanol (2:1, v/v). Lipids were extracted, the organic phase of the extract was dried under nitrogen and dissolved in chloroform, and the lipids were separated by thin-layer chromatography. Radioactivities in the cholesterol and cholesterol ester regions were quantitated using a liquid scintillation counter. Comparison was made to a control apoA-I preparation with LCAT activity of 60±2 nmol/h/mL, which was set as 100%. The initial rates of the enzymatic reaction with purified LCAT were determined by using an enzyme dilution that resulted in a linear reaction rate.
Reconstituting HDL Discs for Efflux Experiments
Reconstituted HDL discs used in efflux experiments were prepared
by the cholate dialysis method using DMPC as described
previously.40,41 Molar ratios of apoA-I (either
total apoA-I from an affected and nonrelated nonaffected subjects or
only the mutant or wild-type isoforms isolated by IEF), DMPC, and
cholate were 1:150:300. ApoA-I, DMPC, and cholate mixtures were
incubated for 12 hours at +37°C, followed by removal of cholate by
dialysis against TBS for 72 hours. Reconstituted particles were
analyzed on native polyacrylamide gradient gels (as
described above) to confirm that apoA-IFin binds
phospholipids and is able to form discoidal particles. Discs were
stored at +4°C and used within 2 weeks.
Cholesterol Efflux In Vitro
Human embryonic fibroblasts (HES cells) were grown in
Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium containing 4 mmol/L
glutamine, streptomycin, penicillin, and 10% fetal calf serum in 35-mm
cell culture plates. Cells were grown until subconfluent and starved
overnight in serum-free OPTI-MEM (Gibco
BRL).3H-labeled cholesterol was
incubated with 20% human albumin at + 37°C and vortexed
briefly, and the resulting
[3H]cholesterol-albumin
mixture (600 000 cpm/plate) was then added onto washed cells. Cells
were labeled overnight in serum-free media (OPTI-MEM),
washed three times with PBS, and incubated for 1 to 24 hours in
serum-free OPTI-MEM with various reconstituted HDL discs
(2.5 to 150 µg/mL) or native HDL (150 to 450 µg/mL).
Media were collected, and cells were washed and lysed in 1 mL of 0.5
mol/L NaOH. After determination of radioactivities by liquid
scintillation counting, cholesterol efflux was expressed as
the percentage of radioactivity present in the medium in relation
to the initial cellular radioactivity. The cholesterol
efflux capacity of the medium alone (accounting for 10 to 15% of the
efflux activity of the acceptors under study) was determined in each
assay and subtracted from the data before their analysis.
Statistical Methods
Mean levels of serum lipids and lipoproteins were compared using
Student's t test. In the case of serum and lipoprotein
triglyceride levels, log transformations of the lipid data
were carried out before comparison.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Serum lipid and lipoprotein profiles (Tables 1
and 2
) showed comparable levels of serum
total cholesterol and phospholipids in affected and
nonaffected family members but slight
hypertriglyceridemia in affected ones. The
amounts of triglycerides and phospholipids present in
the LDL fraction were higher in the affected subjects (75 and 110
mg/dL, respectively) than in the nonaffected subjects (20 and 70
mg/dL, respectively). LDLs of four affected and two nonaffected
subjects were further divided into three fractions according to their
densities (light, dense, and ultra-dense); all LDL fractions of
affected family members showed similar increments of
triglycerides as well as low
cholesterol:triglyceride ratios (data not
shown). However, mean±SE LDL apoB concentrations were similar in
affected (68.0±8.0 mg/dL) and nonaffected individuals
(69.2±1.0 mg/dL); neither were there any significant
differences in apoB concentrations of the LDL subfractions in these two
groups (data not shown). These data indicate that the principal
abnormality of LDL is its enrichment with triglycerides.
IDL fractions of the affected subjects likewise had a high
triglyceride content (Table 1
).
|
|
HDL particle analysis of the affected family members showed not
only quantitative (Tables 1
and 2
) but also compositional changes in
all HDL fractions (Table 3
). The
concentration of total HDL-C was reduced to 20%, apoA-I to 25%, and
apoA-II to 50% of that of the nonaffected subjects. Although HDL
phospholipids and triglycerides were reduced in mutation
carriers, their HDL was, however, disproportionally rich in
phospholipids and triglycerides in relation to the amount
of cholesterol present (Table 3
). Reduction of HDL-C
was particularly significant in the HDL2 density
range, with most of the HDL-C being present in the
HDL3 density range in affected subjects (Table 1
). Because the serum apoA-II concentration in the mutation carriers
was diminished to a lesser extent than that of apoA-I, the ratio of
apoA-II to apoA-I in HDL and its subfractions was high.
ApoA-IFin carriers also showed high ratios of
phospholipid to apoA-I in their HDL. Cholesterol ester
percentage in serum was lower in the nine affected (68.3±1.4%) than
in the nine nonaffected family members (74.8±0.8%,
P<.01). There was a similar trend in
cholesterol ester percentages in HDL (76.0±3.7 versus
83.2±0.7%, P=.07) whereas the cholesterol
ester percentages in LDL were similar in the two groups.
|
Analysis of HDL Particle Size
To examine the HDL particle sizes in more detail, HDL samples from
16 nonaffected and 7 affected subjects were electrophoresed on native
polyacrylamide gradient gels (4% to 22%) and stained with
Coomassie brilliant blue. The data from 7 affected and 7 nonaffected
family members are summarized in Table 4
.
Computer analysis of the scanned gels revealed that the most
prominent characteristic in the affected subjects was an almost total
lack of HDLs at the size range 8.9 to 12.0 nm, corresponding to
HDL2a,b particle diameter
range. HDLs from the affected subjects were detected only within the
size range of 7.8 to 8.9 nm, consistent with the
HDL3 subfraction range. The mean±SE HDL particle
size in the affected subjects was 8.1±0.09 nm. The 16 nonaffected
family members had both HDL2-size particles
(10.7±0.14 nm; range, 9 to 11.35 nm) and
HDL3-size particles (8.0±0.06 nm; range, 7.6 to
8.8 nm).
|
PLTP-Mediated HDL Conversion and CETP Activation
Absence of HDL2-size particles in mutation
carriers may have resulted from impaired conversion of
HDL3 to HDL2 by PLTP. This
was investigated by incubating HDL from an affected and a nonaffected
subject with purified PLTP and subsequent analysis of the
resulting particles on native polyacrylamide gradient gel.
Analysis of the scanned gel by computer (Bio Image system) (Fig 2
) showed a similar appearance of larger,
HDL2-size particles in both the affected and the
nonaffected subjects. Moreover, subsequent formation of small particles
was seen in both the affected and nonaffected subjects (Fig 2
). These
particles were shown to have pre-ß mobility in agarose gel (data not
shown).
|
PLTP activity in two affected subjects (4200 and 4100 nmol PC transferred/mL/h) was normal in comparison to the activity in the normolipidemic control subjects (3850±490 nmol/mL/h). However, CETP activity, measured from two affected and two nonaffected family members, was found to be reduced by approximately 50% in the affected subjects (0.418 and 0.441 versus 0.857 and 0.966 arbitrary units).
Kinetic Studies of ApoA-I
To further clarify the mechanism underlying low apoA-I levels, the
kinetics of apoA-I was investigated in 2
normotriglyceridemic affected family members. Data
of the previous and present kinetic studies are summarized in Table 5
. Altogether, apoA-I kinetic studies
were performed with 4 affected family members and a control group
comprising 13 unrelated subjects. Affected family members had higher
apoA-I FCRs in comparison with the upper 95% confidence limit of the
control subjects. In addition, transport rate of apoA-I was subnormal
in 3 of the 4 affected subjects.
|
LCAT Activation In Vitro
LCAT activation experiments were carried out with reconstituted
proteoliposomes as substrates. Activation of LCAT was determined using
the following apoA-Is: total apoA-I from an
apoA-IFin mutation carrier, purified
apoA-IFin (isolated and purified by IEF) and
purified normal apoA-I isoform 1 from a nonaffected subject (isolated
and purified by IEF), as well as a highly purified control apoA-I. The
possibility that apoA-IFin could have influenced
particle formation by altering protein-phospholipid interaction was
excluded by examining proteoliposomes by gel filtration; all
proteoliposome particles were of the same size. LCAT activation
experiments using apoA-IFin proteoliposomes
revealed a significant reduction in LCAT activation capacity in
comparison with proteoliposomes containing either wild-type apoA-I
isoform or total apoA-I from a heterozygous
apoA-IFin mutation carrier (Table 6
).
|
Cholesterol Efflux From Fibroblasts
Human embryonic fibroblasts (HES cells) were loaded with
albumin-bound
[3H]cholesterol and efflux from the
plasma membrane examined using three different acceptor particles:
total HDL (from an apoA-IFin carrier or
noncarrier), total apoA-I/DMPC discs (apoA-I from an
apoA-IFin carrier or noncarrier), and
IEF-purified apoA-I/DMPC discs (apoA-I from an
apoA-IFin carrier or noncarrier). To clarify
whether the apoA-IFin would result in anomalous
DMPC binding and subsequent disc formation, acceptor particles were
examined by polyacrylamide gradient gel electrophoresis before
use. Analysis of the Coomassie brilliant stained gels showed
the presence of both apoA-IFin- and wild-type
apoA-I-containing particles, and no free apoA-I could be detected (Fig 3
). All efflux experiments were performed
in at least triplicate and repeated at least twice. Initial testing of
the HESS cell system using increasing doses of normal apoA-I/DMPC discs
resulted in efflux curves showing apoA-I dose dependence (data not
shown).
|
Native HDL preparations isolated from two affected subjects (17 and 18)
were compared with total HDL samples from a nonaffected subject
(subject 19) and HDL from an unrelated control subject in different
doses, and efflux values were counted at 1, 2, 5, 7, 9, and 24 hours of
incubation. Efflux values at 2 and 9 hours of incubation are depicted
in Fig 4
. HDL samples from affected
subjects were found to be equally effective promoters of
cholesterol efflux as were the HDL preparations from a
nonaffected family member and a nonrelated control subject (Fig 4A
).
Increasing doses of total apoA-I from an affected and a nonaffected
subject combined with DMPC yielded dose-dependent quantities of
[3H]cholesterol efflux and showed
that apoA-IFin does not impair the promotion of
cholesterol efflux from fibroblasts; in fact,
apoA-IFin tended to result in slightly higher
efflux percentages in comparison with the normal apoA-I (Fig 4B
).
Comparable efflux percentages were also observed when purified
preparations of A-IFin or wild-type apoA-I
isoform 1 were combined with DMPC and used as acceptors (Fig 4C
).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The most prominent feature in the lipoprotein profile of our affected family members was cholesterol-poor and small, dense HDLs, but the metabolic basis for disappearance of larger HDL particles corresponding to the size class of HDL2 is obscure. Hypertriglyceridemia has been proposed to accelerate CETP-mediated exchange of HDL cholesterol esters to triglycerides; triglyceride-rich HDL2 would then be hydrolyzed by hepatic lipase into smaller HDL3 particles. The presence of the CETP transgene in hypertriglyceridemic human apoC-III transgenic mice has actually been shown to greatly reduce HDL particle size.43 CETP activity in the affected subjects was, however, only half of that in the nonaffected subjects and would more likely contribute to the maintenance of larger HDL particles. Elevated serum triglycerides, on the other hand, were present only in five of the mutation carriers, yet all nine mutation carriers exhibited a scarcity of larger HDL2 size particles.
Distribution of serum triglycerides showed a special
characteristic with the affected members, ie, a disproportional
increment of triglycerides within the LDL fraction,
independent of serum total triglyceride level. Only
affected member 17, with a low serum total triglyceride
concentration, had normal levels of LDL triglycerides
(Table 1
). Enrichment of LDL particles with triglycerides
to a various extent has been previously described in different forms of
hypoalphalipoproteinemias including Tangier
disease,44 hypoalphalipoproteinemia resembling
Tangier disease,45 LCAT
deficiency,46 and carriers of the
A-IMilano mutation.27
Several explanations have been proposed. Triglyceride-rich
LDL could reflect an impaired capability of HDL to accept
triglycerides because of quantitative and structural
abnormalities of HDL particles, lack of exchangeable
cholesterol esters, or disturbances of activities
with CETP, hepatic lipase, or lipoprotein lipase. In
apoA-IFin carriers, the quantitative scarcity of
HDL-C may limit the capacity of HDL to accept
triglycerides, which are then redistributed onto the LDL
fraction.
PLTP enhances the conversion of HDL3 particles to
larger HDL2-type particles by a particle fusion
mechanism47 and simultaneous
formation of small, apoA-I-containing pre-ß type
particles.48 The possibility of impaired PLTP
functioning in conversion of HDL3 to
HDL2 has not been addressed in previous studies
on various forms of hypoalphalipoproteinemia. We showed that PLTP in
vitro converts apoA-IFin containing
HDL3 to HDL2 to the same
extent that it converts wild-type HDL3 and that
PLTP activity in serum of the affected subjects is normal. These data
suggest that the lack of HDL2 is not due to
impaired PLTP-mediated conversion mechanisms. The observation that
small (pre-ß type) HDL particles were released in the conversion
experiments in both the affected and nonaffected subjects (Fig 2
),
together with the previous data showing that pre-ß particles are the
initial acceptors of cell-derived
cholesterol,49 indicate that
apoA-IFin does not alter RCT by interfering with
the formation of pre-ß particles, at least via the function of
PLTP.
To further investigate the mechanism of the dominant effect of
A-IFin on HDL-C and apoA-I levels, apoA-I
kinetics was examined in two affected subjects with normal serum
triglyceride levels. We have previously shown that the
mutant apoA-I reassociates with circulating HDL particles to
approximately the same extent as the normal one in postinjection
samples, thus permitting the use of the two-pool method in kinetic
analysis. In accord with our prior studies, apoA-I FCRs of the
affected subjects were higher than those of the control subjects,
suggesting that increased catabolism, possibly associated with
diminished transport rate, of apoA-I protein could contribute to
profoundly diminished HDL-C and apoA-I concentrations (Table 4
).
Hypercatabolism of apoA-I has been observed in a number of inherited
disorders, including carriers of apoA-I
Milano50 and
apoA-IIowa mutations,51
patients with Tangier disease,52 apoA-I
deficiency without a detectable apoA-I gene
mutation,53 and LCAT
deficiency.46 However, increased apoA-I FCR has
been reported also in healthy subjects with low HDL-C with or without
hypertriglyceridemia.32,52,54
In hypertriglyceridemia, the core of HDL
may become rich in triglyceride whereby subsequent
lipolysis of HDL core by hepatic lipase may loosen the binding of
apoA-I to HDL particle and facilitate clearance of apoA-I by the
kidneys.55 Affected family members volunteering
for kinetic studies in the present study had both low serum
triglycerides, in contrast with the previously studied
affected subject 11, yet their FCRs were elevated.
In LCAT deficiencies esterification of cholesterol in the periphery is severely disturbed and maturation of discoid HDL to spherical, cholesterol ester-rich particles is inhibited.56 HDL particles in affected subjects are thus very small in size. Small HDLs occupied almost the whole HDL pool of apoA-IFin carriers, but their LCAT was functioning as cholesterol ester percentages in HDL and LDL were normal and in serum only slightly reduced. However, results from in vitro LCAT activation studies using purified apoA-IFin and artificial proteoliposomes revealed that A-IFin mutant protein diminished LCAT activation to approximately 40% of the normal. The ability of apoA-I to bind phospholipid is a fundamental requirement for LCAT activation. Our in vitro experiments suggest that the ability of apoA-IFin to bind phospholipid is not altered and thus cannot explain the reduction of LCAT activation capacity. It is conceivable that the positive charge difference in apoA-IFin affects either its binding to LCAT or the activation of the enzyme, but the exact mechanism remains unknown. The observation that LCAT activation on interaction with total A-I from affected-subjects was normal implies that apoA-IFin does not interfere with the function of its normal apoA-I counterpart, and half of the normal apoA-I is enough for sufficient LCAT activation in vitro. The total in vivo impact of apoA-IFin on LCAT activation remains obscure and would require a homozygous subject for the apoA-IFin mutation or a transgenic animal model, none of which is available at the moment.
LCAT-activating regions of apoA-I have not yet been fully clarified.
Studies using site-directed mutagenesis have indicated that several
apoA-I domains are important for LCAT activation, but it is especially
the deletion of domains 143 to 164 or 165 to 186 that virtually
abolishes LCAT activation by apoA-I.57,58 The
conserved region, spanning from 143 to 165 with a pattern of positively
charged residues, has been suggested to bind LCAT. In the LCAT
molecule, residues 151 to 174 represent a similar region but
with a distribution of negative charges, and a molecular model has been
presented for residues 151 to 174 of LCAT binding antiparallel
to residues 143 to 165 of apoA-I.8 The importance
of the region is further enlightened by
apoA-ISeattle, a de novo mutation deleting amino
acids from Glu146 to
Arg160, which diminishes HDL-C apoA-I
concentrations to levels below 15% of normal when present in a
heterozygous form.17 Furthermore, point mutations
at residues 143 (Pro
Arg)59 and 165
(Pro
Arg)60,61 of the apoA-I have been shown to
reduce LCAT activation. ApoA-IFin, reducing LCAT
activation by 60% in vitro, further underscores the importance of this
specific area of apoA-I for interaction with LCAT.
Association between genetic HDL deficiencies and premature CAD,
although inevitably an important question, has yet remained obscure.
Risk assessment is hindered by the fact that apoA-I and LCAT defects
are genetically heterogeneous and rare in the population.
In most kindreds with hypoalphalipoproteinemia due to either apoA-I or
LCAT deficiency, no clear association of the genetic defect to CAD has
been observed. An increased propensity for CAD has been demonstrated in
specific conditions, such as homozygosity for the apoA-I Gln 84
Stop
or Q(-2)X mutations14,21 or major rearrangements
of the apoA-I/C-III/apoA-IV gene complex.62,63 An
Italian family with hypoalphalipoproteinemia due to compound
heterozygosity for an apoA-I null allele and apoA-IL 141 R Pisa
mutation was recently described.15 Several
mutation carriers suffered from clinically manifested CAD, but they
also exhibited many additional risk factors such as
hypercholesterolemia, obesity, hypertension,
and smoking. Eight of the nine carriers of the
apoA-IFin mutation were devoid of any clinical
signs of CAD despite their very low serum HDL-C levels. Their increased
CAD risk cannot be excluded due to the relatively small sample size and
young age of five affected family members. However, family member 16
had undergone a coronary bypass operation at the age of 60 and
had no other risk factors for CAD except the low HDL due to
apoA-IFin mutation. In some studies, low HDL-C
has been shown to associate with the occurrence of small, dense LDLs
widely considered to be atherogenic.64
Lipoprotein analysis of apoA-IFin
carriers did not disclose any evidence for increased amounts of small,
dense LDL particles in their serum.
In view of the proposed role of HDL particles as cholesterol acceptors in RCT, we examined the influence apoA-IFin mutation on cholesterol efflux from plasma membranes using in vitro fibroblast cell culture. Comparative efflux experiments with purified A-IFin and their wild type counterpart particles in vitro suggest that the A-IFin mutation does not cause conformational changes interfering with the putative interaction of apoA-I with plasma membrane and passive diffusion of cholesterol from the plasma membrane to the acceptor particles. The domains necessary for cholesterol efflux have not been thoroughly identified and may actually depend on the cell type and particle type used. Thus, apoA-I amino acid residues 74 to 111 were found to be critical for cholesterol efflux from monocytes by monoclonal antibodies,65 but the epitope associated with the efflux of intracellular cholesterol from HepG2 cells was shown to correspond to residues 140 to 15066; the latter epitope was not, however, critical for efflux from plasma membrane, which was the main cholesterol reservoir labeled in the present study. Furthermore, the apoA-I Pro165Arg mutation was shown to slightly decrease cholesterol efflux from macrophages using apoA-I/DMPC particles.41 Comparison of different efflux experiments is hampered by the fact that several factors account for the actual cholesterol efflux in vitro,8,67 and different cell types, labeling methods, and incubation times as well as heterogeneous acceptor particles (size, density, and lipid composition) have been used.
Experiments in which total HDLs are used as acceptors may represent the situation closest to that in vivo. Our results indicate that HDLs from affected members are at least as efficient promoters of cholesterol efflux in vitro as are the HDLs from nonaffected members. Studies with serum of transgenic rats overexpressing human apoA-I have proposed that the main factor determining the cholesterol acceptor capacity would be the concentration of HDL phospholipids.68 Because the ratio of HDL phospholipid to protein is significantly increased in apoA-IFin carriers compared with noncarriers (1.1 versus 0.75, respectively, P<.001) and the amount of total HDLs used in efflux experiments were standardized according to their protein concentration, the higher amounts of phospholipids present in A-IFin HDL acceptor particles might have contributed to in vitro efflux-promoting capacity. On the other hand, protein composition of apoA-IFin HDL shows a disproportionally high amount of apoA-II which has in some,69,70 but not all,71,72 studies shown to inhibit cholesterol efflux depending on the cell type and the cellular location (plasma membrane or intracellular pool) of the cholesterol for efflux.73,74 Therefore, the disproportionally high amount of apoA-II in the HDL might not have affected cholesterol efflux from the plasma membrane in the present study protocol although the situation in vivo may be different. Indeed, apoA-II transgenic mice were shown to be vulnerable to diet-induced atherosclerosis,75 and animals who have apoA-I/apoA-II HDL predominating over apoA-I HDL were at greater risk of aortic cholesterol accumulation.76
Interpretation of the efflux results in vitro concerning the actual
situation in vivo and the possible atherogenicity of
apoA-IFin is hindered by several factors. Despite
extremely low HDL apoA-I levels, even trace amounts of normally
functioning apoA-I protein may be sufficient for the process of RCT in
vivo or that factors other than apoA-I, such as apoE-containing plasma
lipoprotein
-LpE,77 can also trigger
cholesterol efflux from cells. It should also be emphasized
that the protective effect of HDL against CAD may occur also via
processes other than RCT, such as protection of plasma lipoproteins
from peroxidation78 or promotion of
fibrinolysis,79 and the role of
apoA-IFin in these events remains to be
elucidated.
In conclusion, heterozygosity for the apoA-IFin mutation results in severe reduction of serum HDL-C concentration, a virtual lack of large HDL2-size particles, and enhanced catabolism of apoA-I. In vitro studies using reconstituted proteoliposomes showed a decreased capacity of apoA-IFin to activate LCAT but an apparently intact ability to promote cholesterol efflux from fibroblasts. Elucidation of the atherogenic or antiatherogenic potential, if any, of apoA-IFin still requires further studies in additional affected kindreds and in transgenic animals.
| Selected Abbreviations and Acronyms |
|---|
|
|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Pro). A novel mutation causing very
low HDL cholesterol is associated with premature
coronary artery disease. Circulation.
1995;92(suppl):2359. Abstract.
Arg): a mutant that
is defective in activating lecithin:cholesterol
acyltransferase. Eur J Biochem. 1984;144:325331.[Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]