Articles |
From the Center for Human Nutrition and the Departments of Clinical Nutrition, Internal Medicine, and Biochemistry of the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas and the Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Dallas, Tex.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
160 mg/dL and LDLapo B levels
were <120 mg/dL (LDL cholesterol/apo B ratio >1.60). For
patient selection, subjects were challenged with a high fat diet (40%
of total calories as fat, 18% saturated fatty acids, and 400 mg per
day cholesterol) for 6 weeks to confirm persistence of a
high LDL cholesterol/apo B ratio. Thereafter, they were
started on a Step I Diet, and lipoprotein analyses were
repeated. Finally, cholestyramine (16 g per day) was added to the Step
I Diet. The Step I Diet alone significantly reduced the LDL
cholesterol/apo B ratios and produced a trend toward
lowering LDL cholesterol levels. Cholestyramine therapy
further reduced LDL cholesterol levels and maintained a
normal LDL cholesterol/apo B ratio. The present
investigation thus confirms the existence of a form of moderate
hypercholesterolemia that arises from a defect
in LDL composition. In addition, it demonstrates that the combination
of the Step I Diet and cholestyramine therapy corrects this defect and
normalizes LDL levels and LDL composition.
Key Words: cholesterol-enriched LDL high fat diet low fat diet bile acid sequestrant hypercholesterolemia
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
One approach to treatment of this form of hypercholesterolemia may be to reduce the LDL cholesterol/apo B ratio rather than to decrease LDLapo B levels. This approach would be directed toward the primary defect. Two forms of therapy-low fat diets9 and bile acid sequestrants10 11 -have been reported to reduce LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios, and thus they might be the preferred therapy for this type of hypercholesterolemia. For this reason, we identified hypercholesterolemic male patients with relatively normal LDLapo B levels but increased LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios, and we examined their response in sequence to a reduced fat diet and a bile acid sequestrant. The question under consideration was whether these forms of management will reverse this particular type of hypercholesterolemia resulting from a defect in LDL composition.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1.60). In the current study,
during routine evaluation of
hypercholesterolemia, adult men with persistent
hypercholesterolemia were identified as having
normal LDLapo B levels and elevated LDL cholesterol. Ten
such patients were identified who agreed to participate in the study.
Their ages ranged from 45 to 69 years (57.2±6.8 years), and body mass
indexes (BMI) ranged from 20.2 to 30.4 kg/m2 (mean
BMI=25.8±2.5 kg/m2). There were four smokers; two had a
history of coronary heart disease documented by a myocardial
infarction. Four patients had hypertension that was controlled by
medication throughout the study.
Hypercholesterolemia was defined as plasma
levels of LDL cholesterol
160 mg/dL, with plasma
triglycerides <200. These definitions are
consistent with National Cholesterol Education
Program criteria.12 According to these criteria, and by
convention, "LDL" represents the lipoprotein fraction of
density range 1.0063 to 1.063 g/mL and includes true LDL
(d=1.019 to 1.063 g/mL) and IDL. Additionally, patients were
selected to have an elevated LDL cholesterol/apo B ratio.
This type of hypercholesterolemia was defined
as an LDL cholesterol to apo B ratio
1.60 and an LDLapo
B <120 mg/dL; this definition is based on data for normal LDL
composition obtained in a previous investigation.1 The LDL
cholesteroltoapo B ratio used was derived from
true LDL (d=1.019 to 1.063 g/mL). Exclusion criteria
included unstable angina, clinically severe coronary heart
disease, endocrine disorders, liver or renal dysfunction, and treatment
with hypolipidemic agents for at least 2 months before recruitment.
Experimental Design
This study was designed as a single-blind, sequential
intervention study that consisted of three phases. The first phase
lasted 6 weeks. The diet of this phase was composed of 40% of total
calories as fat (18% saturates), 45% carbohydrate, and 15% protein
with a daily dietary cholesterol intake of about 400 mg per
day (high fat diet).1 After 6 weeks, patients had
measurement of levels of plasma lipids, lipoprotein
cholesterol, and LDLapo B for 5 consecutive days. The
ratio of LDL cholesterol/apo B also was determined. Upon
completion of this phase, the subjects were started on the American
Heart Association Step I Diet and concomitantly 16 g per day of placebo
for a bile acid sequestrant (cholestyramine [Questran Lyte]).
Questran Lyte (placebo and active drug) was donated for the study by
Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. The second phase lasted 8 weeks. During this
phase, the Step I Diet was used. This diet consisted of 30% of total
calories as fat (10% saturated fatty acids, 10%
monounsaturates, and 10% polyunsaturates), 55%
carbohydrate, and 15% protein with a daily cholesterol
intake <300 mg. During the last week of the second phase, subjects had
daily measurements of plasma levels of lipids, lipoprotein
cholesterol, and LDLapo B. These measurements were
carried out daily for 5 consecutive days. The third phase of study
consisted of treatment with 16 g per day of active bile acid
sequestrant (Questran Lyte) and continuation of the Step I Diet. The
third phase also lasted 8 weeks; during the last week, measurements of
lipoproteins were repeated. Throughout the study, subjects were
evaluated regularly every fourth week and encouraged to maintain
adherence to the diet and drug or placebo. They were counseled by a
dietitian on diet adherence and maintenance of constant body
weight. The average coefficient of variation for the weight during the
study was 3%.
The ratios of LDL cholesterol to apo B in normolipidemic subjects studied with the same baseline diet and clinical conditions were included for comparison with hypercholesterolemic patients. These control subjects had similar ages and BMI to the hypercholesterolemic patients in this study, and they have been described previously.1 All subjects gave informed written consent for participation in the study. The protocol was approved by the Institutional Review Board for Investigation in Humans at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Dallas, Tex.
Procedures
Twenty milliliters of blood was collected each time after a
12-hour fast. Blood was drawn by venipuncture into tubes
containing disodium EDTA at a concentration of 1 mg/mL. Plasma was
separated shortly after blood collection at 4°C and stored at the
same temperature for analysis. Preservatives were added to the
plasma samples as follows: gentamicin sulfate (0.005%),
chloramphenicol (0.005%), sodium azide (0.01%), and Trasylol (100
IU/mL). Levels of plasma total cholesterol and
triglyceride were measured enzymatically,13 14
and HDL cholesterol was measured after precipitation of apo
Bcontaining lipoproteins with the use of 0.55 mmol/L phosphotungstic
acid and 25 mmol/L magnesium chloride.15
Cholesterol in VLDL+IDL (d<1.019 g/mL) and LDL
was measured as follows: 4 mL of plasma was adjusted to a density of
1.019 g/mL as detailed previously.16 VLDL+IDL isolation
was carried out by ultracentrifugation for 18 hours
at 39 000 rpm. The top 2 mL was collected quantitatively; total
cholesterol was measured in the fractions of density less
than and greater than 1.019 g/mL. Recoveries of cholesterol
were >96%. VLDL+IDL cholesterol (d<1.019
g/mL) was normalized for recoveries, and absolute concentration of LDL
cholesterol was estimated as the difference between total
plasma cholesterol and the sum of HDL and VLDL+IDL
cholesterol (d<1.019 g/mL).
Levels of apo B in LDL and VLDL+IDL were determined by a modification of the Lowry-Folin procedure as detailed elsewhere.16 17 Briefly, LDL (d=1.019 to 1.063 g/mL) was isolated from the plasma infranatant of density 1.019 g/mL. Total cholesterol was measured enzymatically, and apolipoprotein was measured chemically.16 17 The ratio of LDL cholesterol/apo B was calculated. Absolute concentrations of apo B in LDL were calculated as the product of the ratio of cholesterol/apo B in isolated LDL and the absolute concentration of LDL cholesterol. Levels of apo B in VLDL+IDL were measured by precipitating apo B using a final concentration of 50% isopropyl alcohol, delipidating the precipitate with 100% alcohol, and redissolving apo B with 1.5 mol/L sodium deoxycholic acid and 0.1N NaOH.16 18 Protein content was measured chemically using the modification of Markwell et al19 of the procedure of Lowry et al.20 Total apo B was calculated as the sum of VLDL+IDLapo B and LDLapo B.
The coefficients of variation for the enzymatic method for
cholesterol quantitation and for the chemical method of
quantifying apo B were
3.0%. The latter method was standardized in
our laboratory as follows. First, the standard for the Markwell
modification19 of the Lowry-Folin procedure20
is bovine serum albumin obtained from the National Institute of
Standards and Technology.17 Second, for direct measurement
of apo B in LDL and VLDL+IDL, a chromogenicity factor of 1
was used for reasons detailed previously17 ; third, levels
of apo B measured by the chemical method and with immunochemical
methods for apo B give similar values with a high correlation
coefficient.17
The current study required the isolation of LDL (d=1.019 to 1.063 g/mL) to determine the ratio of LDL cholesterol to apo B in the lipoprotein of these patients. It was also necessary to determine the physiological coefficients of variation of these ratios in the patients selected for study. These coefficients were determined over a period of 5 days during each of the three phases of study.
Patients were tested for familial defective apo B-100 (FDB-3500 mutation) by gene amplification and cleavage with Msp I.21 Briefly, genomic DNA was extracted from whole blood by phenol-chloroform extraction and ethanol precipitation. Two primers were used during the polymerase chain reaction. Primer 1 was 5' CCAACACTTACTTGAATTCCAAGAGCACCC 3', and primer 2 was 5' CTGTGCTCCCAGAGGGAATATATGCGTTGG 3'. These primers were obtained from the Cardiology Department of the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas. The digestion products were electrophoresed on a nondenaturing gel of 12% acrylamide. Two DNA markers were used for estimation of the size of the digestion products-Lambda C1 857-Dral and Msp/puc 18. The bands were visualized under UV light after treatment of the gels with ethidium bromide. All patients showed a single band of 120 bp. Subjects heterozygous for the glutamine for arginine mutation would be expected to have two bands of 149 and 120 bp, respectively, while the homozygous case would have only one band of 149 bp.21
Statistical Analysis
Data are expressed as mean±SD. Comparison of means was made by
repeated measures ANOVA with a Bonferroni adjustment for multiplicity
of treatments. An
of 0.05/3 (0.0167) was considered statistically
significant. Coefficients of physiological
variation were determined for the ratios of LDL
cholesterol/apo B, and these coefficients were also
compared by repeated measures ANOVA.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Effects of therapy on LDLs are presented in Table 2
. Individual responses for LDL cholesterol
and LDLapo B levels and the ratios of LDL cholesterol/apo
B are shown also. None of the current
hypercholesterolemic patients were found to have
FDB-3500. In the current patients, the mean LDL cholesterol
levels were markedly increased compared with the control group, but
LDLapo B levels were only modestly higher. The result was a striking
increase in LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios. This higher
ratio, and not a higher LDLapo B level, was the predominant cause of
hypercholesterolemia in this group. Several
patients had reductions in both LDL cholesterol and apo B
on the Step I Diet, but the responses were inconsistent.
With the Step I Diet, a trend toward reduction of LDL
cholesterol level was noted, but again the decrease was not
statistically significant. Furthermore, no change was observed in
LDLapo B concentrations on the Step I Diet alone. Addition of
cholestyramine to the Step I Diet resulted in a significant decrease in
both LDL cholesterol and LDL-apo B concentration. On this
combination, levels approached those of a group of normal men of
similar age (control group) that were previously
reported.1
|
The ratios of LDL cholesterol/apo B were fairly constant
for multiple determinations for each individual during each of the
phases of study. The average coefficients of
physiological variation ranged from 2% to 4%
during the study. As shown in Table 2
, the Step I Diet gave a striking
decrease in mean LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios, and this
response was maintained and enhanced somewhat by the addition of
cholestyramine. Most of the patients had a definite decrease in ratio
on the Step I Diet, and several showed a further decrease on the
addition of cholestyramine. On the combined therapy, the mean LDL
cholesterol/apo B ratio approached that of the control
group.
Effects of the Step I Diet with and without cholestyramine on other
lipid and apolipoprotein variables are given in Table 3
. Combined diet plus drug therapy produced significant
decreases in non-HDL cholesterol levels, total apo B
levels, and non-HDL cholesterol/total apo B ratios. These
changes could be explained almost entirely by changes in the LDL
fraction because VLDL+IDL cholesterol and VLDL+IDLapo B
levels, and VLDL+IDL cholesterol/apo B ratios were
unaltered by diet and drug therapy.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
It is uncertain whether this form of hypercholesterolemia is as atherogenic as other forms in which LDLapo B concentrations are concomitantly increased. Only two of the current patients had existing coronary heart disease. This is an important question because if hypercholesterolemia resulting from a high LDL cholesterol/apo B ratio does not enhance atherogenicity, many patients might be unnecessarily treated with cholesterol-lowering drugs. This question seems particularly important for women, in whom this form of hypercholesterolemia seems particularly common.8 In our view, prospective studies that include measurements of LDL (1.019 to 1.063 g/mL) compositions are needed to resolve this issue. Recently it has been reported that patients having coronary heart disease frequently have "large" LDL particles,26 but whether these "large" LDL, which may include IDL-like remnant lipoproteins, are common in patients with a high LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios remains to be determined.
In healthy normolipidemic men, about 15% of the variation in LDL cholesterol levels can be explained by variation in LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios; the remainder of the variation is due to LDLapo B levels.16 LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios for individuals on a given diet are relatively constant, as shown in the current study. The average coefficient of variation for the ratios of current patients based on multiple determinations ranged from 2% to 4% during each phase of the study. Several workers likewise have shown that LDL physicochemical properties are relatively constant within individuals.27 28 29 Indeed, the particle composition might be expected to be more constant than the levels of apo B because particle composition reflects the steady state of a number of metabolic processes. These include the actions of lipid transfer proteins and lipolytic enzymes. In contrast, levels of LDLapo B are more subject to hemodynamic factors, and these are more variable from day to day.
The primary aim of this study was to determine whether the combination of the Step I Diet and cholestyramine will reverse an elevated LDL cholesterol/apo B ratio. The effects of the Step I Diet alone were tested first. A low fat diet has been reported to be associated with relatively low LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios in epidemiological studies30 and to lower LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios in a clinical trial.9 The results of the current study documented that reduction in intake of saturated fatty acids and replacement with carbohydrate significantly lowered LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios. In fact, LDLapo B levels were reduced little if any by the low fat diet; this finding is consistent with both epidemiological studies30 and a clinical trial.9 Previous investigations thus suggested that low fat diets reduced the cholesterol content of LDL particles more than they lowered the LDLapo B levels. This action was particularly noticeable in our current patients with high LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios, but it may be a general mechanism whereby low fat diets lower LDL cholesterol concentrations. Previous studies31 32 have shown that low fat diets variably reduce LDL cholesterol levels in patients with moderate hypercholesterolemia. In the present study, the Step I Diet inconsistently reduced LDL cholesterol levels. In a few patients, LDLapo B levels rose somewhat; in contrast, there was a consistent reduction in LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios.
This decrease in ratio contrasts with that which results from replacement of saturated fatty acids with unsaturated fatty acids, either polyunsaturated or monounsaturated fatty acids. An early report33 raised the possibility that the primary action of polyunsaturated fats for lowering LDL cholesterol levels is to reduce the LDL cholesterol/apo B ratio and not to lower LDLapo B levels. Subsequent investigations34 35 demonstrated clearly that replacement of saturated fatty acids with unsaturated fatty acids reduces LDLapo B levels as well as LDL cholesterol levels. This parallel decline most likely reflects an increase in the LDL receptormediated clearance of LDL brought about by the use of unsaturated fatty acids.36
How might the decrease in LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios result from the use of a low fat diet? In our view, the most likely mechanism is the substitution of triglycerides for cholesterol esters in the core of newly secreted apo Bcontaining lipoproteins. The rise in triglyceride levels commonly observed on low fat diets supports this mechanism.37 38 In other words, it seems probable that the number of lipoprotein particles secreted by the liver is not reduced during the low fat diet. The lack of decrease in LDLapo B levels is in accord with this possibility. Thus, while the magnitude of the reduction of LDL cholesterol levels by low fat, high carbohydrate diets and high unsaturated fat diets may be similar in many patients,38 39 the mechanism for this lowering may be different. In the case of hypercholesterolemia caused by an increased LDL cholesterol/apo B ratio, a low fat diet may be the preferable approach because it will correct the primary abnormality. As indicated in the present and previous studies, some patients fail to demonstrate a lowering of LDL cholesterol levels, most likely because of an inconsistent response in LDLapo B concentrations.
Previous investigations10 11 also reveal that bile acid
sequestrants can modify LDL composition by decreasing the
cholesterol content of LDL particles. In the current study,
this trend was further noted. In several patients, cholestyramine
therapy caused a reduction in the LDL cholesterol/apo B
ratio beyond that produced by the low fat diet (Table 2
). Since bile
acid sequestrants are known to enhance VLDL-triglyceride
secretion rates40 41 and triglyceride
levels18 42 in some patients, a portion of their action
may be to replace cholesterol esters with
triglycerides in lipoproteins destined for secretion.
However, bile acid sequestrants almost certainly increase the activity
of LDL receptors as well43 ; in the current study this
latter action was suggested by a decrease in LDLapo B levels as well
as LDL cholesterol. In contrast to bile acid sequestrants,
treatment of patients having moderate
hypercholesterolemia with HMG CoA reductase
inhibitors causes a lowering of both LDLapo B and LDL
cholesterol levels with little change in LDL
composition.8 44 This finding suggests that the
predominant mechanism of statins in patients with moderate
hypercholesterolemia is to enhance the activity
of LDL receptors and not to change the cholesterol content
of newly secreted lipoproteins.
In summary, the present investigation confirms the existence of a type of moderate hypercholesterolemia in which the defect consists primarily of an increase in LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios; plasma levels of LDLapo B are relatively normal. Treatment of these patients with a low fat diet tended to normalize LDL cholesterol levels by normalizing LDL cholesterol/apo B ratios; little reduction in LDLapo B levels was noted. Addition of bile acid sequestrants further reduced LDL cholesterol/apo B in some patients but produced a lowering of LDLapo B levels as well. The combination of a low fat diet and a bile acid sequestrant may be particularly efficacious for this form of hypercholesterolemia, especially because it appears to reverse the underlying cause of the high LDL cholesterol levels.
Although the current study extends our previous report defining the existence of hypercholesterolemia caused by cholesterol-enriched LDL particles and demonstrates an effective therapeutic approach to the condition, several important questions remain to be answered. The mechanisms underlying this form of hypercholesterolemia have not been defined. Neither have the mechanisms whereby the defect is corrected by the combination of a low fat diet and cholestyramine therapy been determined. A particularly important question is the relative atherogenicity of this type of hypercholesterolemia compared with those in which the number of LDL particles is increased. Thus, considering the relatively high frequency of hypercholesterolemia resulting from cholesterol-enriched LDL particles, further investigation is needed to resolve these questions.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received August 9, 1995; accepted January 3, 1996.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
ATVB Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 1996 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |