Articles |
the Department of Cardiovascular Pathology (F.D.K., S.J.L., R.V.), Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, Washington, DC; Cardiovascular Biological Research (A.S.K., E.E.L., S.M.W.), Medical Research Division, American Cyanamid Co, Lederle Laboratories, Pearl River, NY; the Biomedical Engineering Center (J.F.C., E.E.H.), The Ohio State University, Columbus; and the Department of Biomedical Engineering Research Institute (J.F.C.), The Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, Ohio.
Correspondence to Renu Virmani, MD, Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, Cardiovascular Pathology, 14th and Alaska Aves NW, Washington, DC 20306-6000. E-mail virmani@email.afip.osd.mil.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
5000 cholesterol weeks; below this limit lesions were minimal, and above this value, the degree of plaque correlated with TPC exposure. Furthermore, a wide biological variability occurred among rabbits with respect to individual responsiveness to dietary cholesterol. In the aorta, various types of plaques, from fatty streaks to atheromatous lesions, were observed, depending on the degree of cholesterol intake. Diets consisting of <0.15% cholesterol resulted in the development of fatty streak lesions, while transitional lesions and atheromatous plaques were mostly found with higher cholesterol feeding. Coronary artery atherosclerosis was present in >50% of animals fed diets
0.15% cholesterol. Despite the level of TPC exposure, coronary lesions in epicardial vessels were generally the fibrous type, whereas intramyocardial arteries demonstrated predominantly intimal foam cells. In conclusion, by adjusting dietary cholesterol intake and selecting rabbits with a similar responsiveness to cholesterol, the overall cholesterol exposure can be more closely controlled to minimize the inherent individual variability among animals in this model. The nature of the target lesion must also be carefully considered, because the efficacy of some treatments may depend on the type of atherosclerotic plaque.
Key Words: atherosclerosis rabbit cholesterol acyl coenzyme A:cholesterol acyltransferase sudanophilia
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The goal of the present study was to further characterize the cholesterol-fed rabbit model in an effort to better define the individual variability in cholesterol exposure and to identify the types of plaques encountered in response to feeding various amounts of low-level dietary cholesterol (0.05% to 0.25%). The extent of topographic distribution, morphology, and biochemical composition of atherosclerotic lesions were assessed. Such information regarding cholesterol exposure, lesion type, and biological variability of individual responsiveness to dietary cholesterol will serve to establish a better model for the evaluation of therapeutic strategies designed to limit the progression of atherosclerotic disease in humans.
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Experimental Design
After 2 weeks of quarantine, 70 rabbits underwent a 1-week prescreening process to assess their response to cholesterol feeding before being randomized to the various dietary study groups. For this initial experiment, rabbits were fed standard rabbit chow (Purina) supplemented with 0.25% in weight of cholesterol (USP grade, anhydrous, Sigma Chemical Co) dissolved in 6% peanut oil (Planter's) (Table 1
). The atherogenic diet was prepared by dissolving the cholesterol in the peanut oil and thoroughly coating the pellets of rabbit chow with this mixture. All animals received 125 g cholesterol feed/d; water was provided ad libitum. Food consumption was recorded daily, and body weight was measured before and after the test period. At the conclusion of the cholesterol screen, animals were phlebotomized through the marginal ear vein, and blood (10 mL) was collected in EDTA-containing tubes for determination of TPC.
|
During the screening period, body weight and food consumption were similar among all animals; TPC values ranged between 150 and 550 mg/dL. For randomization, rabbits with the highest and lowest TPC levels were pooled so that cholesterol values were equally distributed among the five study groups. Animals were subsequently switched to atherogenic diets consisting of either 0.05% (n=10), 0.10% (n=10), 0.15% (n=10), 0.20% (n=10), or 0.25% (n=30) cholesterol. The diets were prepared as described above. Throughout the duration of the experiment (31 to 32 weeks), animals were bled and body weights were recorded every second week. Blood samples were analyzed for total serum cholesterol and liver enzymes (ALT, AST, and ALP). Elevated ALT and AST levels serve as indicators of hepatocellular injury; increased ALP indicates hepatobiliary obstructive disease.
Tissue Preparation
A final blood sample was obtained at the completion of the study, and rabbits were euthanized with an intravenous overdose of sodium pentobarbital (120 mg/kg). The thoracic cavity and abdomen were opened. Portions of the small intestine (jejunum) and liver were excised and frozen in liquid nitrogen for preparation of microsomes for analysis of ACAT activity. The aorta (ascending aorta to iliac bifurcation) was removed, trimmed of all adherent fat, cut open longitudinally, and pinned on a paraffin block with the endothelial surface exposed. The opened aorta was divided in half longitudinally along its ventral aspect with the transection line passing through the origins of the celiac, superior mesenteric, and inferior mesenteric arteries. The anatomic left half of the aorta was processed for evaluation of sudanophilia, and the right half was analyzed for lipid content and ACAT activity.
For evaluation of coronary atherosclerosis, the heart was removed, and sections were prepared by slicing the whole heart from the apex at 2-mm intervals to just above the aortic valve parallel to the atrioventricular sulcus.
Lipid Extraction and Analysis of Tissue and Plasma Cholesterol
TPC was measured by using enzymatic techniques with a Centrifichem System 400 Autoanalyzer (Union Carbide Co). Tissue samples from the liver, aortic arch (origin to first set of intercostal arteries), and thoracic aorta (first set of intercostal arteries to the level of the diaphragm) were gently blotted, and weights were determined. The tissue samples (0.06 to 0.28 g) were homogenized in 1.6 mL distilled water on ice with a Brinkman Polytron at full speed for 15 seconds. Total lipids were extracted from equivalent 0.8-mL aliquots according to the methods of Folch et al.12 Cholesterol was measured by using gas chromatography with cholesterol methyl ether (Sigma) as an internal standard. The total cholesterol content was measured after hydrolysis at 70°C for 45 minutes in 0.2 mL of 33% potassium hydroxide in water (wt/vol) and 2.0 mL of 95% ethanol. The concentration of esterified cholesterol was calculated by assessing the difference between the concentrations of unesterified and total cholesterol.
Analysis of ACAT Activity
Liver and Intestine
Microsomes from liver and intestine were prepared13 and stored at -70°C until analysis. ACAT activity was assayed in microsomes according to the methods of Hashimoto et al.14 Briefly, 30 µL of microsome suspension was added to 500 µL potassium hydrogen phosphate buffer (0.2 mol/L, pH 7.4) containing 0.2% bovine serum albumin. The reaction was initiated by adding 20 µL [14C]palmitoyl coenzyme A (55.5 mCi/mmol, New England Nuclear) and run for 4 minutes at 37°C in a shaker water bath. Enzymatic reactions were terminated by adding 1 mL ethanol, and lipids were extracted by vortexing with 3 mL petroleum ether. The lipids were separated by silica gel G thin-layer chromatography, and the CE band (Rf=0.94) was identified by using iodine vapor. The CEs were assayed by using scintillation counting. Recovery of the 14C-labeled CE added to microsomes was 89% to 95%.
Aortic Arch
The adventitia was removed, and the medial-intimal layers weighing approximately 70 to 200 mg were homogenized in 1 mL potassium phosphate buffer (154 mmol/L, pH 7.4) by using a Brinkman Polytron. Homogenates were centrifuged at 500g for 5 minutes, and the supernatant was assayed for ACAT activity. Aliquots of aortic homogenates were analyzed for protein content by using the Bio-Rad protein assay procedure. Measurement of ACAT activity was performed essentially as described above with the following changes. The aortic homogenate (20 µL) was preincubated for 15 minutes in 20 µL potassium phosphate buffer (0.2 mol/L, pH 7.4). The reaction was initiated by adding 10 µL [14C]palmitoyl coenzyme A and run for 10 minutes. Assays were terminated by adding ethanol (500 µL), and petroleum ether was added for lipid extraction. Separation of CEs followed the procedures described above.
Morphological Evaluation of Aortic Sudanophilia
For evaluation of aortic sudanophilia, the left half of the aorta was stretched, pinned on cork board, immersion-fixed in 10% buffered formalin, and stored at room temperature. Specimens were subsequently stained with Sudan IV for macroscopic determination of sudanophilia (fat content) and photographed. Sudanophilia, as shown by dark red regions corresponding to the uptake of Sudan IV by fat, was quantified by digital image analysis at Ohio State University by using the methods of Cornhill et al.15 In all cases, the degree and topographic distribution of aortic sudanophilia were measured from the ascending aorta to the branch of the celiac artery. In brief, digital images captured from 35-mm color slides were subdivided into triangular sections by using anatomic landmarks (ie, ostia) to outline the vertices; these were used to execute a linear transformation of the raw images to a standard template, thereby removing anatomic variation between vessels. Images were then edited to remove artifacts and were segmented into sudanophilic and nonsudanophilic areas by using an average boundary gradient algorithm to determine a threshold for image segmentation. Finally, probability-of-occurrence maps were generated by calculating the probability of sudanophilia occurring at each point on the entire aortic surface. These maps represent the percentage of animals with lesions at that particular site.15
Histomorphometry
Intimal and medial thickness measurements were determined on 3-mm transverse segments taken from four sites along the length of the entire aorta: (1) the ascending aorta, (2) the descending aorta between the third and fourth intercostal arteries, (3) just above the renal arteries, and (4) the aorta above the bifurcation of the iliac arteries. These segments are referred to as the ascending aorta, descending thoracic, thoracic abdominal, and abdominal aorta, respectively.
Light Microscopy
Aortic specimens were dehydrated in a graded series of alcohols and xylene and embedded in paraffin for light microscopic evaluation. Multiple 4-µm-thick sections were cut and stained with hematoxylin and eosin and Movat Pentachrome stains. The aortic sections were magnified (x45), and intimal and medial thickness measurements (in millimeters) were made by a skilled observer using computerized planimetry who was blinded to the various groups. Both intimal and medial thicknesses were measured at the sites showing maximal intimal thickening; the intimal-medial border was defined by parallel elastic lamellae. Intimal and medial thickness measurements were averaged for each study group. The intimal and medial thickness ratio was calculated as the intimal/medial thicknessx100 for each animal and was averaged for each study group.
Immunocytochemistry
Semiquantitative analysis was performed on serial sections immunostained with the muscle actinspecific monoclonal antibody HHF35 (dilution 1:200) and the rabbit macrophage-specific monoclonal antibody RAM 11 (dilution 1:100; Dako).16 Lesions were classified as fatty streak (macrophage-derived foam cells with little intervening extracellular matrix); transitional (SMCs interspersed with macrophages, proteoglycans with or without the rare presence of cholesterol clefts); or atheromatous (presence of an SMC-rich fibrous cap, cholesterol clefts, and necrotic core).
Evaluation of Coronary Atherosclerosis
Each myocardial section (base to apex, five slices per heart) was processed for light microscopy and stained with Movat Pentachrome. Myocardial sections were evaluated by an observer unaware of the dietary group. The number of cases demonstrating intimal thickening in epicardial or intramyocardial vessels (ie, frequency of animals with lesions) was determined. For the ratio of coronary vessels with lesions, the total number of both epicardial and intramyocardial muscular arteries from the base and middle myocardial sections, respectively, was counted. The number of arteries demonstrating atherosclerotic plaque was then determined and divided by the total number of the respective vessels present in each myocardial section.
Statistical Analysis
Statistical comparisons between groups were made by using ANOVA and linear correlation between two variables (StatView, version 4.01, for the Macintosh, Abacus Concepts, Inc). A quantitative estimate of the cumulative total exposure to cholesterol for individual animals was determined by plotting the biweekly total cholesterol values and calculating the areas under the curves using the trapezoidal rule.17 Quantitative results are reported as mean±SEM, and statistical differences between groups were determined by using Scheffe`s test. Calculations of confidence intervals at 95% for TPC exposure and estimates of variability in individual responsiveness to dietary cholesterol were performed by using Statistical Analysis Software (SAS Institute). Differences among dietary groups were considered significant at a probability value of .05 or less.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
0.15% cholesterol remained stable throughout the protocol. In rabbits fed >0.15% cholesterol, liver enzymes were essentially normal until the 12th week of cholesterol feeding, when a gradual rise was observed; ALT and AST levels at euthanasia in these dietary groups were elevated approximately twofold (the borderline upper limit of normal18 ) over precholesterol diet values. ALP levels were similar among dietary groups throughout the duration of cholesterol feeding. Three animals in the 0.25% dietary cholesterol group demonstrated a severe loss of appetite and died during the final 8 weeks of the study. Gross examinations of major organs revealed hepatomegaly with evidence of bile stasis. The TPC level in these three animals at the time of death was 3257±266 mg/dL, and cholesterol data from these rabbits were not included in the final analysis.
TPC and Arterial Wall Cholesterol Exposure
After the 1-week prescreen, during which all rabbits were fed 0.25% cholesterol, animals were grouped such that TPC values were similar (306±38, 310±38, 310±34, 302±31, and 304±20 mg/dL [0.05%, 0.10%, 0.15%, 0.20%, and 0.25% cholesterol, respectively]). After randomizing the rabbits to the various dietary regimens, TPC in animals fed 0.05% to 0.15% dietary cholesterol gradually decreased over the first 6 to 8 weeks of feeding and then stabilized at a quantity below the starting value (Fig 1
). In animals fed
0.15% dietary cholesterol, no significant differences were noted in plasma cholesterol among groups at any time. In animals receiving >0.15% dietary cholesterol, TPC rose steadily throughout the study (Fig 1
). Statistical differences in plasma cholesterol in rabbits fed 0.20% and 0.25% dietary cholesterol relative to the 0.05% cholesterol group were apparent by the first and second weeks of randomized feeding (P=.02 and .002, respectively) and remained significantly elevated throughout the experiment (Fig 1
). At euthanasia, plasma cholesterol levels were 70±7, 109±15, 186±30, 1457±347, and 1706±161 mg/mL for the 0.05%, 0.10%, 0.15%, 0.20%, and 0.25% dietary cholesterol groups, respectively.
|
The exposure of the arterial wall to cholesterol over the duration of the experiment (cumulative cholesterol-week values) in individual rabbits was estimated from the area under the curve of the TPC versus duration of cholesterol feeding. The cumulative cholesterol-week values in animals receiving 0.05% to 0.15% dietary cholesterol did not differ statistically, suggesting that the degree of cholesterol exposure between these three groups was similar. Cumulative cholesterol-week values in rabbits receiving 0.20% and 0.25% dietary cholesterol were also not statistically different from each other. Increasing dietary cholesterol from 0.05% to 0.15% resulted in a less than twofold stepwise increase in TPC exposure, whereas the cholesterol-week values in animals receiving 0.20% and 0.25% cholesterol were significantly higher (four- to fivefold increase; P<.008) relative to those values in the 0.05% to 0.15% cholesterol groups.
Sudanophilic Area and Distribution
The degree of aortic sudanophilia increased with escalating levels of dietary cholesterol (Fig 2
). Raising dietary cholesterol from 0.05% to 0.15% resulted in a modest increase in aortic sudanophilia (1.7±0.6% to 13.9±4.5%), whereas lesion area increased exponentially with cholesterol intakes >0.15% (lesion area was 47.7±10.4% and 64±4.9% in the 0.20% and 0.25% cholesterol groups, respectively).
|
Tissue Biochemistry
Tissue Cholesterol
Total tissue cholesterol accumulated progressively with increasing dietary cholesterol, with maximal deposition in the aortic arch region relative to the thoracic aorta. Esterified cholesterol was present only in rabbits fed
0.15% dietary cholesterol (Fig 3
). In all groups, the free (unesterified) cholesterol/CE ratio was never <1 except in animals receiving 0.25% dietary cholesterol, demonstrating that there was generally more free cholesterol than CE.
|
ACAT Activity
Increasing dietary cholesterol from 0.05% to 0.15% resulted in modest increases in aortic ACAT activity (1.7±0.3 to 10.3±4.5 pmol·min-1·mg protein-1, respectively). In animals fed >0.15% cholesterol, ACAT activity increased markedly (63.6±11.9 and 73.7±14 pmol·min-1·mg protein-1 in the 0.20% and 0.25% dietary groups, respectively).
In the intestine, increasing dietary cholesterol from 0.05% to 0.25% progressively increased ACAT activity (109±9.4 to 288±50.4 pmol·min-1·protein-1, respectively). Liver ACAT activity at euthanasia in rabbits fed 0.05% cholesterol was 65.5 pmol·min-1·protein-1. Levels peaked in animals fed 0.15% cholesterol (191.2±26.1 pmol·min-1·protein-1) and remained elevated with higher cholesterol intake (0.20% and 0.25%).
Correlation of TPC Exposure With Aortic Sudanophilia
The extent of Sudan IV staining in each rabbit aorta as a function of cumulative TPC exposure is presented in Fig 4
. Linear regression analysis for the individual dietary groups showed a positive correlation between TPC exposure and sudanophilia in animals fed
0.10% cholesterol. In addition, a threshold level of TPC exposure was apparent at
5000 cholesterol weeks. Below this level lesions were minimal or absent, and above it lesions correlated with the degree of cholesterol exposure. The strongest correlation of Sudan IV staining with TPC exposure was observed in rabbits fed 0.15% cholesterol (R2=.88). Increasing the cholesterol content in the diet weakened this relationship (R2=.51 and .28 in the 0.20% and 0.25% dietary cholesterol groups, respectively).
|
Individual Variability Among Animals in Response to the Cholesterol Diets
The variation among individual rabbits in response to the different cholesterol diets is presented in Table 2
. The mean percent difference in TPC exposure of two hypothetical experimental groups to satisfy statistical significance based on the observed means of the reported dietary groups was calculated. Given the individual variability in response to dietary cholesterol in the present study, a >50% difference in mean TPC exposure value is predicted for two hypothetical groups consisting of 10 animals each to become statistically significant. This required difference in mean cholesterol values is reduced to approximately 30% when the number of animals is increased to 26, as shown in the experimental group fed 0.25% cholesterol.
|
Plaque Distribution and Intimal Thickness
The probability distribution of sudanophilia for the ascending aorta to the celiac branch in the individual dietary groups is shown in Fig 5
. All animals demonstrated the typical atherosclerotic lesion distribution and characteristics of the cholesterol-fed rabbit model. In rabbits fed 0.05% to 0.15% dietary cholesterol, the greatest probability (
50%) of lesion formation was confined to the greater curvature of the aorta along the dorsal surface. With increasing dietary cholesterol (>0.15%), high probability regions were observed throughout the arch to the distal thoracic aorta.
|
The mean intimal/medial thickness ratios in the various aortic regions are shown in Table 3
. In animals fed 0.05% to 0.15% cholesterol, intimal thickening as a result of cholesterol feeding was mostly negligible, ranging from zero to
0.15±0.09. In animals fed >0.15% dietary cholesterol, the intimal/medial thickness ratio was markedly increased relative to those of the lower dietary cholesterol groups. In the 0.20% to 0.25% dietary cholesterol groups, intimal/medial thickness ratios ranged from 0.18±0.12 to 2.00±0.28. Intimal/medial thickness ratios were never >1 except for animals in the 0.25% dietary cholesterol group.
|
Plaque Morphology
Aorta
Most of the aortic sections from animals fed
0.1% cholesterol had microscopically detectable lesions and displayed various lesion morphologies (Fig 6
). Atherosclerotic plaques in rabbits fed <0.15% cholesterol were generally fatty streaks, consisting predominantly of intimal macrophage-derived foam cells, and demonstrated few, if any, SMCs. Atherosclerotic plaques in rabbits fed
0.15% cholesterol consisted of transitional and advanced lesions, with an increased frequency of advanced lesions in the higher dietary cholesterol groups (Table 4
). Transitional plaques showed SMCs scattered among foamy macrophages, with evidence of extracellular matrix formation consisting of proteoglycans. In transitional lesions, macrophages were the predominant cell type, comprising
50% of the plaque; SMC composition was
30% (Table 5
). Lesions identified as atheromatous plaques were characterized by an evolving lipid-rich necrotic core filled with cellular debris and cholesterol clefts covered by a well-developed fibrous cap consisting of SMCs, extracellular matrix, and focal foam-cell infiltrate. In atheromatous plaques,
70% of the lesion consisted of acellular material (proteoglycans, collagen, and necrotic debris), while SMCs and macrophages were equally present. Intimal calcification was not observed in any of the lesions examined (Table 5
).
|
|
|
Coronary Arteries
The frequency of epicardial and intramyocardial arteries demonstrating coronary atherosclerosis from rabbits among the various dietary groups is shown in Table 6
. Coronary atherosclerosis was only observed in rabbits fed
0.1% cholesterol and, when present, was localized to both the epicardial and intramyocardial arteries; however, it was more extensive in the latter. Epicardial coronary atherosclerosis in animals fed 0.10% cholesterol was rare (2 of 10 cases examined); however, the frequency of detectable epicardial lesions increased with escalating levels of dietary cholesterol, such that the majority of rabbits fed 0.25% dietary cholesterol demonstrated coronary lesions in at least one vessel. In contrast to aortic findings, atherosclerotic plaques in coronary arteries displayed two distinct histological profiles. Atherosclerotic lesions in epicardial coronary arteries consisted mostly of SMCs interspersed with a small number of macrophage-derived foam cells. Lesions in intramyocardial arteries consisted of macrophage-derived foam cells along with proteoglycans and occasional foci of necrosis.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
5000 cholesterol weeks, below which lesion development is minimal or absent and above which lesion area is associated with TPC exposure. Intake of
0.15% dietary cholesterol was associated with marked elevations in aortic wall esterified cholesterol content, ACAT activity, topographic distribution, and intimal thickness relative to the groups fed lower amounts of cholesterol. In the aorta, lesion type was similarly affected by the degree of dietary cholesterol; rabbits fed
0.15% cholesterol showed predominantly transitional lesions (advanced fatty streaks) and atheromatous fibrous plaques. This relationship, however, was not observed in coronary arteries, where lesion type was unchanged by increased cholesterol feeding. Taken together, these data suggest that a number of critical variables should be carefully considered when using the cholesterol-fed rabbit model to assess the efficacy of potential antiatherogenic drugs. Efforts to minimize the individual variability in response to dietary cholesterol by preselecting animals with similar responsiveness to cholesterol as well as an awareness of the type of lesion produced by varying degrees of cholesterol exposure should be accounted for in the experimental design.
Diet-Induced Atherosclerosis in the Rabbit
Diet-induced hypercholesterolemia in the rabbit is caused by an accumulation of exogenous cholesterol. Rabbits are sensitive to atherosclerosis induced by dietary cholesterol because they are unable to increase sterol excretion, resulting in enhanced liver export of cholesteryl esterrich lipoproteins into the circulation.19 20 21 Under these conditions, the principal carriers of cholesterol in the circulation are LDL and ß-VLDL, the latter being the major cholesterol transport vehicle when TPC values reach approximately 700 to 800 mg/dL.22 23 Atherogenic lipoproteins are markedly increased; consequently, the number of lipoprotein receptors is reduced, prolonging the residence time of circulating lipids.24 In cholesterol-fed rabbits, lesion-prone areas selectively accumulate these atherogenic lipoproteins from the circulation, resulting in lesion development.
Cholesterol Exposure and Sudanophilia
In humans, the influence of plasma cholesterol on the degree of aortic and coronary artery atherosclerosis is well established.25 26 27 In the cholesterol-fed rabbit, earlier reports have demonstrated a general relationship of either TPC with aortic cholesterol content and/or aortic atherosclerosis scores, without statistical correlation.22 28 More recent studies suggest a statistically significant correlation of average plasma cholesterol with aortic cholesterol content and/or intimal lesion area.7 29 30 31 32 However, few studies have systematically correlated varying dietary regimens to the extent of lesion formation in the cholesterol-fed rabbit. In a study by Bocan et al,31 a significant correlation was observed in pooled data from rabbits fed increasing amounts of cholesterol/fat (0% to 2.0%) for 9 weeks. However, the validity of an analysis of "pooled" data is in question, since one would have to assume that similar degrees of cholesterol exposure would produce the same amount of sudanophilia independent of the amount of cholesterol in the diet.
In the present study, rabbits fed dietary cholesterol of 0.05% and 0.1% failed to show a good correlation of TPC exposure with atherosclerotic plaque, possibly due to the kinetics of disease progression or a necessity to achieve some arbitrary threshold for atherosclerosis to become evident; such a threshold was evident in our data at
5000 cholesterol weeks. Similarly, cholesterol diets >0.15% may induce factors that may lower the predictive value of circulating cholesterol, such as the saturation of an atherogenic lipoprotein species, whereby levels above a certain threshold do not proportionally increase atherosclerosis.
Although cholesterol exposure can be controlled by modifying the amount of cholesterol in the diet, this technique alone has limited value due to the inherent variability in individual responsiveness to cholesterol feeding in the rabbit, as exemplified by our data. Using the observed mean values for TPC exposure among rabbits in the reported dietary groups, we predict that a hypothetical group would require a >50% mean difference in cholesterol exposure to become statistically different, assuming an equivalent number of 10 animals per group. One method to control for this variability intrinsic to the rabbit model is to increase the number of animals in each group. For instance, a hypothetical group consisting of 26 animals would require only an approximate >30% difference in mean TPC exposure for statistical significance, as shown by our study. Of course, maintenance of large numbers of animals minimizes the cost effectiveness of the rabbit model. A better approach to manage this variability more closely may require not only restricting cholesterol exposure but also carefully selecting rabbits with similar responsiveness to the diet prior to experimentation.
Lesion Morphology
It has become increasingly apparent that lesion morphology, at least in rabbits, may be selectively altered by titrating the level of dietary cholesterol and duration of feeding. Short-term feeding of dietary cholesterol in the rabbit (
2%) yields high levels of circulating cholesterol, resulting in macrophage-derived foam-cell lesions.29 33 34 35 Conversely, reducing the level of dietary cholesterol has been reported to produce lesions containing large numbers of SMCs, cholesterol clefts, and necrotic debris, a model more representative of human atherosclerotic disease.7 8 9 10 11 More advanced complicated lesions that are characteristic of human atherosclerosis are also observed with intermittent, rather than continuous, feeding of an atherogenic diet.36
Few studies describe a range of lesions (fatty streaks to advanced fibrous plaques) with cholesterol feeding in the rabbit.16 37 38 Only in the study by Daley et al38 did animals develop aortic lesions demonstrating a progression of atherosclerosis from fatty streaks to atheromatous lesions. In their study, rabbits were fed low-level cholesterol (0.125% to 0.5% by weight) for 6 months. However, it is unclear in this investigation how cholesterol exposure influenced lesion type. Other studies have used casein diets supplemented with either 0.2% cholesterol16 or 19% butter fat37 and longer periods of feeding (6 to 60 months). Our study clearly showed the development of advanced atherosclerotic lesions with low-level (0.20% to 0.25%) cholesterol feeding for 8 months. Diets of 0.05% to 0.15% cholesterol produced mostly fatty streaks and transitional lesions. As in the aforementioned studies, lesion type in our rabbits was more precisely characterized by using monoclonal antibodies to identify the composition of macrophages and SMCs within plaques. In fatty streaks and transitional lesions, the percentage of macrophages versus SMCs was greater, whereas more advanced lesions showed a relative increase in acellular areas and SMC number.
Some studies suggest that the development of advanced lesions in the cholesterol-fed rabbit may depend on the age of the animal. An increased prevalence of aortic fibroatheromatous plaques has been described in aged (3 to 4.5 years) rabbits versus young (4-month-old) animals fed low-level cholesterol (0.1% or 2%) for 18 months.9 34 These findings are in contrast with the present study, in which atheromatous lesions were observed within 8 months of cholesterol feeding in young rabbits (4 to 8 months of age) with escalating levels of dietary cholesterol. Similarly, Daley et al38 found that >70% of plaques sampled along the entire aorta from young rabbits (aged 6 months) fed 0.125% to 0.5% dietary cholesterol for 6 months were advanced lesions.
Lesion Topography
Computerized planimetry was used to precisely assess the extent and topographic distribution of intimal surface involved by atherosclerotic plaque in animals fed varying degrees of low-level cholesterol. Lesion-prone areas were confined to the upper thoracic aorta only in animals fed <0.15% cholesterol. In rabbits fed >0.15% cholesterol, regions of highest probability were found throughout the entire length of the vessel, with frequent extension well into the abdominal aorta. In rabbits fed 0.125% to 0.5% cholesterol for 6 months, Daley et al39 report abdominal lesions covering 39% of intimal surface area, much greater than previously reported percentages of surface area involvement of abdominal aorta in cholesterol-fed rabbits.40 41 42 Nevertheless, the topography of aortic lesions in the rabbit is clearly influenced by the level and duration of circulating cholesterol; with sufficient cholesterol exposure, significant sudanophilic lesions can be observed at all anatomic locations of the aorta.
Esterified Cholesterol and Lesion Severity
Cholesterol esterification by cells of the arterial wall has been demonstrated in various species, including humans.43 44 CEs are localized within the intima and are found both extracellularly and intracellularly within monocyte/macrophages or smooth musclederived foam cells.45 46 In rabbits maintained on diets containing <0.15% cholesterol, no evidence of CE formation in the arterial wall was observed. However, the esterified cholesterol content of the lesions was evident at cholesterol diets of 0.15% and was substantially increased when animals were fed higher amounts of dietary cholesterol. CE deposition within the plaque may, at least in part, influence the morphological appearance of lesions. Studies of human plaques as well as experimental atherosclerosis models demonstrate increased lesion severity with a rise in arterial wall esterified cholesterol content.47 48 In addition to affecting plaque morphology, increased CE content may weaken the stability of the plaque (lipid in the form of CE softens plaque), thereby increasing the risk of rupture and thrombosis.49
An essential protein responsible for the esterification of cholesterol is the microsomal enzyme ACAT. Previous studies report low basal ACAT activity in normal arteries from various animal species and humans.50 51 However, ACAT activity is enhanced severalfold after experimental induction of atherosclerosis in animals and in human atherosclerotic tissue.50 The susceptibility of a species to atherosclerosis does not appear to correlate with increased ACAT activity; the rat, one of the species most resistant to induction of atherosclerosis, demonstrates high levels of microsomal cholesterol esterifying activity in the aorta relative to atherosclerosis-sensitive species such as the rabbit.52 Rather than producing an increased vulnerability to plaque development, induction of ACAT through the formation of CEs may strongly affect the conversion of a foam-cell lesion to a more advanced stage of atherosclerosis. In the present study induction of aortic wall ACAT activity with increased presence of CEs was associated with advanced atherosclerotic lesions.
Coronary Atherosclerosis
Hypercholesterolemia in the rabbit is associated with the development and progression of coronary atherosclerosis.1 5 53 Intramyocardial plaques are relatively common, and lesions consist primarily of macrophage-derived foam cells. However, unlike lesions in intramyocardial vessels, atherosclerotic plaques in the main epicardial coronary arteries in the cholesterol-fed rabbit have been reported as rare.1 5 However, Hunt and Duncan53 report extensive atherosclerosis in the epicardial coronary arteries of Dutch Belted rabbits fed a diet of 0.06% cholesterol, 14% hydrogenated coconut oil, and 20% casein. Similarly, the prevalence of epicardial coronary artery disease in our study was also significant; increasing levels of dietary cholesterol consistently produced epicardial lesions in virtually all animals fed >0.15% cholesterol. In our study, atherosclerotic lesions in epicardial vessels were rich in SMCs, unlike intramyocardial plaques, which consisted primarily of macrophage-derived foam cells. Interestingly, in contrast to the aorta, lesion type in coronary arteries was not affected by the level of cholesterol exposure. The mechanism of why foam-cell lesions in intramyocardial vessels are resistant to conversion to a more advanced stage of plaque development is unclear.
Conclusions
By selecting rabbits with similar responsiveness to cholesterol and adjusting cholesterol intake, the overall cholesterol exposure can be more closely controlled to produce various degrees and stages (early fatty streaks to fibrous plaques) of atherosclerotic lesions. Thus, we recommend that animals be screened to select those with similar responses to cholesterol. Careful consideration must also be given to the nature of the target lesion, because the efficacy of some treatments depends on the stage of plaque development.
| Selected Abbreviations and Acronyms |
|---|
|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Received September 5, 1995;
revision received April 4, 1996;
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-dihydroequilin sulfate, a conjugated equine estrogen, and ethynylestradiol on atherosclerosis in cholesterol-fed rabbits. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 1995;15:837-846.This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
N. Ota, S. Soga, T. Hase, I. Tokimitsu, and T. Murase Dietary Diacylglycerol Induces the Regression of Atherosclerosis in Rabbits J. Nutr., May 1, 2007; 137(5): 1194 - 1199. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Ritsch, I. Tancevski, W. Schgoer, C. Pfeifhofer, R. Gander, P. Eller, B. Foeger, U. Stanzl, and J. R. Patsch Molecular characterization of rabbit scavenger receptor class B types I and II: portal to central vein gradient of expression in the liver J. Lipid Res., February 1, 2004; 45(2): 214 - 222. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Castro, A. Diez-Juan, M. J. Cortes, and V. Andres Distinct Regulation of Mitogen-activated Protein Kinases and p27Kip1 in Smooth Muscle Cells from Different Vascular Beds. A POTENTIAL ROLE IN ESTABLISHING REGIONAL PHENOTYPIC VARIANCE J. Biol. Chem., February 7, 2003; 278(7): 4482 - 4490. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| < |