Articles |
From the Departments of Pathology (R.P.T., E.G.B.) and Biochemistry (R.P.T.), University of Vermont, Colchester; the Departments of Biostatistics (D.Y.) and of Medicine, Epidemiology, and Health Services (B.M.P.), University of Washington, Seattle; the Departments of Medicine and Epidemiology, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Md (L.P.F.); the Department of Epidemiology, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (G.H.); the Department of Medicine, University of California, Davis (M.L.); the Department of Radiology, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Mass (J.F.P.); and the Epidemiology and Biometry Program, National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Md (P.J.S.).
Correspondence to Russell P. Tracy, PhD, Department of Pathology, University of Vermont, Aquatec Bldg, Room T205, 55A S Park Dr, Colchester, VT 05446.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: cardiovascular disease blood coagulation factors elderly risk factors
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the aforementioned studies, there have been very few participants older than 65 years. In the two studies that examined the issue of fibrinogen and older age, the NPHS and the Framingham Study, fibrinogen was associated with CVD risk in older men in the Framingham Study in the initial analysis,7 but was found to be less so in a later analysis,8 whereas fibrinogen was reported to be unassociated with CVD risk in men older than 65 years in the NPHS.3
Since the careful studies of DeWood et al,14 most investigators believe that thrombosis is important as the precipitating event of acute ischemic disease in CVD. However, recent evidence has pointed to an additional role for thrombosis as a major factor in atherosclerotic plaque growth.15 16 17 In any case, the question of the relationship between coagulation factors, whose plasma levels may be related to thrombotic potential, and CVD risk is important in the elderly: while many elderly have atherosclerosis, some individuals appear able to avoid major ischemic events. It is possible that risk factors in the middle-aged, which may more often relate to atherogenesis, may become less important in the elderly, while measures of thrombotic potential may become more important as age increases.18
We have recently reported the distributions of fibrinogen, factor VII, and factor VIII levels in the elderly population of the CHS and the relations of these coagulation factors to age, race, and sex.19 A second recent CHS report demonstrated that fibrinogen, and to a lesser degree factor VIII, was associated with a global "index" of subclinical disease, but factor VII was not.20 In this article we report the associations of these coagulation factors to specific measures of subclinical CVD in the full cohort as well as in those with and without prevalent, clinical CVD at baseline. A report of the correlates of fibrinogen, factor VII, and factor VIII is in preparation (M. Cushman MD, et al, 1995, unpublished data).
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Participants answered standardized questionnaires that included
medical history, quality of life, social support, personal health
habits, and diet. Information on medication use was also
collected,23 as were data on physical
activity.24 The clinical exam included measures of
anthropometry, blood pressure,25 26 ECG,27
carotid ultrasonography,28
echocardiography,29 and blood
chemistry profiles,30 including an oral glucose tolerance
test. Elevated blood pressure was defined as either "borderline"
(systolic blood pressure measured while the subject was seated by
random-zero sphygmomanometry [mean of five measurements; the
"random" aspect decreases bias] between 140 and 159 mm Hg or
mean diastolic blood pressure between 90 and 94 mm Hg) or
"hypertension" (mean systolic blood pressure
160 mm Hg, mean
diastolic blood pressure
95 mm Hg, or use of
antihypertensive medications). Abnormal glucose tolerance was defined
as "impaired" (fasting glucose <140 mg/dL and 2-hour postload
glucose between 140 and 199 mg/dL) or "diabetes" (fasting glucose
140 mg/dL, 2-hour postload glucose
200 mg/dL, self-reported
diabetes, or use of either insulin or oral hypoglycemic
medications).31 "Smoking" was defined as
"never," "former," or "current"; no restrictions were
placed on the time since cessation of smoking for the "former"
category.
The entire CHS cohort comprised 5201 individuals. For this study, 177 individuals were considered ineligible due to missing data or warfarin use, leaving 5024 eligible participants (97%). For analytical purposes, in addition to the those eligible from the full cohort, two mutually exclusive subgroups were defined: those with prevalent, clinical CVD at baseline (clinical CVD subgroup) and those without it (clinical CVDfree subgroup). The prevalent-disease subgroup consisted of those individuals who had any of the following characteristics: definite, possible, or unreported (ie, discovered during the examination) myocardial infarction, angina, stroke, transient ischemic attacks, congestive heart failure, or claudication; past coronary artery angioplasty, carotid endarterectomy, coronary artery bypass surgery, lower-extremity angioplasty, or pacemaker implantation; or rheumatic diseaserelated valve dysfunction. This subgroup consisted of 1672 of the 5024 eligible participants (33%). All other eligible participants (3352, or 67%) were designated as the clinical CVDfree subgroup. All statistical analyses were performed on these two subgroups as well as on the full cohort.
Measures of Subclinical Disease
Blood pressure (measured while the subject was seated) was used
to calculate the AAI, with a value <0.9 considered
abnormal.32 In the multivariate models,
AAI was used as a continuous variable. Twelve-lead resting ECGs
were obtained for all participants; abnormal ECG results and use of the
ECG to define LVM have been described.27 For dichotomized
analyses, an LVM value >80th percentile (sex specific) was
considered abnormal. Ultrasound and quality control methods have been
described in detail elsewhere.28 Duplex ultrasonography of
the carotid arteries was performed, and results were expressed either
as percent stenosis or as CCA or ICA wall thickness.
Stenosis is reported as percentage of the arterial
lumen occluded. For dichotomized analyses, stenosis in
either the ICA or CCA >25% was considered abnormal. In the ANOVA
model, the larger percent stenosis of the CCA or ICA was used
to establish six strata: <1%, 1% through 24%, 25% through 49%,
50% through 74%, 75% through 99%, and 100%. Wall thickness values
were used in both dichotomized (>80th percentile considered abnormal)
and multivariate (continuous) models. M-mode,
two-dimensional, and Doppler
echocardiography was performed, with results
expressed as either normal or abnormal LVEF, normal or abnormal wall
motion, and LAD as described elsewhere.29 Wall motion and
LVEF were used only in dichotomized analyses; LAD was used in
both dichotomized (>80th percentile considered abnormal) and
multivariate (continuous) models.
Blood Measurements
Methods of phlebotomy, sample handling, and shipment to the
central laboratory at the University of Vermont, as well as the results
of our quality-assurance programs, have been
described.30 Plasma prepared with EDTA was used for
analysis of lipids (cholesterol, HDL
cholesterol, and triglycerides); citrated
plasma kept at 4°C during preparation was used for fibrinogen and
factor VIII measurements, and citrated plasma kept at room temperature
(to avoid cold activation33 ) was used for factor VII
assays. Separation of serum or plasma occurred within 30 to 40 minutes
of venipuncture. Aliquots were frozen on-site to
-70°C and shipped in batch to the central laboratory at the
University of Vermont.
Serum insulin was measured by solid-phase radioimmunoassay using serum-based standards (Diagnostic Products), and glucose was measured using a Kodak Ektachem 700 Analyzer (Eastman Kodak). Fasting lipids were measured on an Olympus Demand system (Olympus Corp) that had been standardized in the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Lipid Standardization program. LDL cholesterol was estimated using the Friedewald formula.34
Plasma fibrinogen, reported in milligrams per deciliter, was measured as the rate of clot formation by a semiautomated, modified Clauss method35 using a BBL Fibrometer (Becton-Dickinson). We used the Data-Fi fibrinogen calibration reference plasma (Baxter Healthcare Corp) as our standard. Results were confirmed by participation in the College of American Pathologists' comprehensive coagulation quality-assurance program and by assaying the CAP Fibrinogen Reference material. During the course of the study, internal-reference plasma samples were used to assess reproducibility of results. The mean monthly CV for our fibrinogen control plasma was 3.09%.
Assays for factor VII, reported as percent of a normal plasma pool, were performed with a Coag-A-Mate X2 instrument (Organon Teknika) using factor VIIimmunodeficient plasma (Baxter-Dade) and the human placental thromboplastin Thromborel S (Behring). Standardization was performed by assaying reference plasma from the World Health Organization.36 The mean monthly CV for the factor VII assay was 5.31%.
Assays for factor VIII, also reported as percent of a normal plasma pool, were performed by using the Coag-A-Mate, factor VIIIimmunodeficient plasma, and partial thromboplastin reagent from Organon Teknika. Standardization was done to World Health Organization reference plasma.37 The mean monthly CV for the factor VIII assay was 9.67%.
Statistical Analyses
All analyses were performed on microcomputers
using the SPSS statistical packages.38 The
first analyses for the full cohort and both subgroups were
2 analyses of the demographic frequency data in
Table 1
. Then we performed ANOVA comparisons of age-adjusted mean
values for the coagulation factors in those with and without positive
results for the 10 measures of subclinical CVD: LAD, LVM, maximum left
or right CCA stenosis, maximum left or right ICA
stenosis (>80th or <80th percentile), wall motion, LVEF, ECG
(normal or abnormal); AAI (
0.9 or >0.9 in either leg), maximum
stenosis in either the left or right CCA or ICA (>25% or
not), and any of the above (in the disease-free subgroup only).
Although a relatively large number of comparisons were made (n=84), the
significance level was established at P
.05 because we were
using this analysis as a "screen" and wanted to include
as many associations as possible. Measures of subclinical disease that
were associated with significant differences in any of the
age-adjusted coagulation factors in the clinical CVDfree subgroup
were used in multivariate models to explore these
associations more fully. The maximum stenosis variable,
available as an ordered, discrete variable with six levels, was
used in an ANOVA model in which the coagulation factor of interest was
the dependent variable. The coagulation factor of interest was also
used as a continuous variable in univariate and
multiple linear regression models to predict the subclinical disease
measure. The association of factor VIII with abnormal wall motion, a
dichotomous variable ("normal" or "borderline" in one
category and "abnormal" in the other), was explored by multiple
logistic regression. The covariates in all multivariate
analyses were the known CVD risk factors: age; sex; height;
weight; smoking status; levels of LDL cholesterol, HDL
cholesterol, fasting glucose; and systolic and
diastolic blood pressures. There are three models for each
subclinical CVD measure, corresponding to the full cohort and the
clinical CVD and clinical CVDfree subgroups.
|
To estimate the effect of coagulation factors in the multivariate models, we calculated a value that we called the "effect ratio." To calculate this value, we estimated the change in the predicted subclinical disease measure associated with a 1-SD change in the coagulation factor of interest. We then divided this number by a value equal to 1 SD for each predicted variable. Therefore, the effect ratio is the fraction of a 1-SD change in the disease variable that can be "explained" by a 1-SD change in the coagulation variable. In this way the effect sizes of the coagulation variables can be more easily compared.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 analyses of the frequencies in each
category that compare groups indicated that men were not different with
respect to age, race, or weight but were different with respect to the
other risk factor variables (P
.05). As expected, the
differences were always in the direction of the clinical CVD subgroup
having a greater proportion of men in the "worse" risk factor
category compared with the clinical CVDfree subgroup and the full
cohort. The three groups of women showed the same pattern, except they
did not differ with respect to smoking status.
ANOVA Analyses
Table 2
lists the age-adjusted mean values for
fibrinogen, factor VII, and factor VIII stratified by the 10 indicators
of subclinical CVD, in the full cohort as well as the clinical CVD
subgroup and the clinical CVDfree subgroup. Fig 1
illustrates the difference in mean values (value for those with
subclinical disease minus the value for those without) for the three
coagulation factors in the clinical CVDfree subgroup.
|
|
Fibrinogen showed a consistent, positive association with all
10 measures of subclinical disease when all three groups were
considered (Table 2
). Fibrinogen was significantly associated with 8 of
the 10 measures of subclinical disease in at least one of the three
groups. In the clinical CVDfree subgroup, fibrinogen level was
significantly associated with stenosis, CCA and ICA wall
thickness, and AAI (Table 2
and Fig 1
). Factor VIII showed a similar
pattern of association: 9 of 10 associations were positive in at least
one group; 8 of 10 positive associations were statistically significant
in at least one group; and there were 3 positive, significant
associations in the clinical CVDfree subgroup. Compared with the
results for fibrinogen, there were fewer associations with
ultrasound-based measures and more associations with
echocardiographic measures (Table 2
and Fig 1
).
Factor VII, in contrast, showed no consistent pattern. When all
three groups were considered, factor VII was positively associated with
5 measures (3 significant associations) and negatively associated with
5 (3 significant associations). In the clinical CVDfree subgroup,
there were 2 significant associations, both positive: LVM and CCA wall
thickness (Table 2
and Fig 1
).
Multivariate Analyses
Multivariate analyses were based on
results from the clinical CVDfree subgroup, as we anticipated less
confounding due to the absence of prevalent, clinical CVD. Fig 2
illustrates the mean values for fibrinogen in all
three participant groups after adjustment for a variety of other CVD
risk factors and stratified by percent stenosis. Data for
factor VII and factor VIII are also shown for comparison purposes,
although three factors were not associated with percent
stenosis in the bivariate analyses. Fibrinogen was
associated with percent stenosis in a graded, positive manner
in all three groups, whereas the other two variables were not.
|
Tables 3
, 4
, and 5
show
the results of multiple linear regression models that were designed to
determine whether the coagulation factors were significantly associated
with the subclinical disease measures in multivariate
analysis. Table 3
shows the results for fibrinogen and three
subclinical disease measures: CCA wall thickness, ICA wall thickness,
and AAI. For CCA wall thickness, fibrinogen was significant in the
bivariate model but not significant in any group in the
multivariate models. However, for ICA wall thickness,
fibrinogen was significant in all three groups in
multivariate models. Fibrinogen was also strongly
associated in multivariate models with AAI in all three
groups.
|
|
|
Although factor VII was associated with CCA wall thickness in the ANOVA
analysis, there was no significant association in the
regression models (Table 4
). There was also no significant association
between factor VII and LVM in the multivariate
regression models.
As shown in Table 5
, factor VIII retained significant although weak
associations with AAI and LAD in the multivariate
regression models in the full cohort but not in the two subgroups.
Table 6
illustrates the association of factor VIII with
abnormal wall motion in logistic regression models. Factor VIII was
significantly and independently associated with abnormal wall motion in
the clinical CVD subgroup and in the full cohort.
|
Fig 3
illustrates the effect ratios, as described in
"Methods," for the multiple regression models and the odds ratios
(which compare values for factor VIII at the 25th and 75th percentiles)
for the wall motion logistic regression models. The significant
positive association of fibrinogen with CCA wall thickness was
essentially removed by adjustment for other risk factors, whereas
adjustment had little effect on the associations of fibrinogen with ICA
wall thickness and AAI. A change in fibrinogen level equivalent in
magnitude to a 1-SD change in fibrinogen distribution was associated
with a change of approximately 5% of an SD in wall thickness and 10%
of an SD in AAI. Adjustment for other risk factors removed any
significant association between factor VII and CCA wall thickness and
LVM and any significant association with factor VIII in the clinical
CVDfree subgroup. However, adjustment did not completely remove the
associations between factor VIII and AAI in the full cohort, with a
change in factor VIII equivalent to 1 SD in the factor VIII
distribution associated with a change in AAI equivalent to 4% of an
SD. On the basis of logistic regression models, the odds ratio for
abnormal wall motion (ie, the 75th percentile versus the 25th
percentile for factor VIII) was approximately 1.2 to 1.3.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Fibrinogen
In prospective studies, there is evidence that both
supports7 and rejects3 8 the hypothesis that
fibrinogen is associated with CVD in the elderly. However, fibrinogen
has been shown to be associated with prevalent and incident CVD in
various studies of middle-aged people.2 4 5 6 7 8 The nature
of this association remains unclear. Plasma fibrinogen levels are
responsive to pro-inflammatory, cytokine-mediated
regulation39 and therefore, may reflect ongoing tissue
damage associated with atherothrombosis. However, there are several
potential mechanisms by which increased fibrinogen levels may cause
increased atherothrombosis, including increased platelet
cross-linking,40 increased fibrin
formation,41 increased blood viscosity,6 42
and decreased fibrinolysis (M. Nesheim, PhD, 1995,
personal communication). Smith et al43 44 have suggested
that fibrinogen might be important even in the early atherogenic
processes. We have recently suggested that atherothrombotic disease
might upregulate fibrinogen levels and that this in turn might lead to
more disease through one or more of the mechanisms mentioned
above.18 45 The role of genetics in regulating fibrinogen
levels is unclear; some studies suggest a prominent
role,46 47 while other studies have found little evidence
for genetic regulation.48 49
In simple age-adjusted analyses, fibrinogen showed extensive associations with several measures of subclinical CVD. On the basis of these analyses, we explored three disease measures derived from ultrasonographic data and one based on AAI. Use of ultrasonographic estimates of carotid atherosclerosis to approximate coronary atherothrombotic disease has been validated in several studies.50 Our finding that fibrinogen was associated with carotid artery wall thickness in the elderly, even in those in the clinical CVDfree subgroup, supports our preliminary results51 and those of others in middle-aged subjects.52 53 These associations remained even after adjustment for a variety of CVD risk factors, including smoking, age, and race, all of which are important correlates of fibrinogen. This finding is consistent with the notion that fibrinogen plays an important role in the causal pathway for atherosclerosis or that significant "inflammation" accompanies asymptomatic atherosclerosis.
In previous studies of the middle-aged, atherosclerosis severity was estimated by using measures of intimal-medial thickening that averaged several views of ICAs and CCAs.52 We separately analyzed data for the CCAs and ICAs. The association of fibrinogen with wall thickness was stronger for the ICA than for the CCA. The segment of ICA that was used for analysis is adjacent to the carotid artery bifurcation and hence, may be subject to greater rheological stress than the segment of CCA used for analysis. Any increase in blood viscosity caused by increased fibrinogen levels may have a greater effect in the ICA than in the CCA. This notion is consistent with reports that atherosclerotic disease is greater in the ICA than in the CCA.54 55 We also report a strong, independent association between fibrinogen and carotid artery stenosis, even in the clinical CVDfree subgroup. This association with stenosis, taken together with the results concerning wall thickness, supports the position that fibrinogen is an important marker of atherosclerotic disease.
The association of fibrinogen with AAI in the clinical CVDfree subgroup supports this position. AAI is believed to be a marker for generalized atherosclerosis as well as peripheral vascular disease56 57 and has been extensively evaluated in the CHS population.32 In a manner similar to the association of fibrinogen with ultrasound variables, the association of AAI with fibrinogen in this cross-sectional study may reflect the presence of an inflammatory atherosclerotic process, a causal effect of elevated fibrinogen, or both. Also, as pointed out by Ernst and Resch58 and others,6 59 the importance of the rheological effect of fibrinogen must be established. Prospective studies from the CHS should help us understand these relations more clearly.
Factor VII
Factor VII has not been previously studied in the elderly general
population. Unlike fibrinogen, factor VII has not been
consistently associated with CVD in the middle-aged. In one
prospective study, the NPHS, factor VII was a strong, independent
predictor of incident CVD.2 Also, cross-sectional data
indicate that higher factor VII values are found in young adults at
risk for CVD60 ; subjects with
hypertriglyceridemia,9
hypercholesterolemia, or mixed
hyperlipidemia61 ; male survivors of
myocardial infarction11 ; and subjects at risk for
thromboembolic disease.62 However, another prospective
study failed to find a significant association between factor VII and
incident CVD,13 and one large, cross-sectional study
also failed to associate factor VII with prevalent CVD in
middle-aged individuals.52
In the present study, we failed to identify any consistent association of factor VII with subclinical measures of CVD. In simple age-adjusted analyses, mean factor VII values were both higher and lower in the presence of various measures of subclinical disease. For the two measures studied in more detail, ie, LVM and CCA wall thickness, although bivariate analysis of means indicated that factor VII values were higher in the presence of disease, the regression analyses done initially without adjustment indicated negative associations. After adjustment, no significant association remained. These results lend support to the position that factor VII may not be a risk factor for CVD.
However, this position must be approached cautiously. One striking feature of factor VII is that there are many different assay "methods" available.63 We used a clot-rate, one-stage factor VII assay that utilized human-derived reagents. However, other investigators, the NPHS group in particular, used assays that employed bovine reagents, at least in part. It is well known that the origin of assay reagents and many other factors influence the factor VII assay. In fact, Miller et al64 have argued that the type of assay used may partly explain the differences between studies. However, this possibility remains to be verified.
Factor VII, unlike fibrinogen and factor VIII, is known to be associated with dietary fat intake,65 66 67 68 and dietary fat intake is a potential confounder in these analyses. However, because fasting lipid levels are only weakly associated with dietary fat, adjustment for this potential confounder is difficult. It is important to establish the role of factor VII in CVD, as factor VII levels can be modified to a greater degree than fibrinogen levels by behavioral changes, such as dietary modification.
Factor VIII
In age-adjusted analyses of the clinical CVDfree
subgroup, factor VIII was significantly associated with LAD, abnormal
wall motion, and AAI. The overall pattern was essentially positive (ie,
higher mean values in disease) but less pronounced than that for
fibrinogen (Fig 1
). In multivariate analyses,
significant associations of factor VIII were found with AAI in the full
cohort, which remained even after adjustment for other risk
factors, and with wall motion abnormalities in all but the adjusted
clinical CVDfree subgroup model. The AAI results confirm the study
described by Folsom et al52 in a middle-aged
population. The wall motion results are a new finding and suggest a
role for factor VIII as a key procoagulant. However, although factor
VIII is a key procoagulant enzymatic cofactor, it is also an
inflammation-responsive plasma protein like fibrinogen. Therefore,
analysis of factor VIII as a risk factor has the same
uncertainties concerning causality as does analysis of
fibrinogen. There is some evidence, although less convincing than that
for fibrinogen, to support the idea that factor VIII is a CVD risk
factor. The NPHS group observed a positive but nonsignificant
association with incident CVD,2 3 69 and we reported in
preliminary analysis an association with prevalent
cerebrovascular disease.51 Others have also reported
associations of factor VIII with incident CVD in vascular disease
patients.70 However, while the key role played by factor
VIII in the assembly of the enzymatic complex responsible for factor X
activation cannot be denied, support for the position that factor VIII
is an important CVD risk factor in the general population must await
studies of incident disease.
Summary
It is becoming well established that fibrinogen is a risk
factor for CVD in middle-aged populations. There are some data that
have linked hemostatic factors to subclinical CVD in the
middle-aged, and the present study extends these associations
to include the elderly by using a comprehensive array of subclinical
CVD measures. Fibrinogen and to a lesser extent factor VIII were
associated with subclinical disease in a variety of forms; the
associations for factor VII were weaker and less consistent.
Prospective data from the CHS will shed further light on the
associations of coagulation factors with CVD in older people.
| Selected Abbreviations and Acronyms |
|---|
|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
Participating institutions and principal staff are listed in the "Acknowledgments."
Received April 14, 1995; accepted July 3, 1995.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||