Articles |
A Substitution at Position -75 of the Apolipoprotein A-I Gene Promoter
From the Clinical Research Institute of Montreal, Montreal, Canada.
Correspondence to Dr Anne Minnich, Clinical Research Institute of Montreal, 110 Pine Avenue, West, Montreal, PQ, Canada H2W 1R7. E-mail minnica@ircm.umontreal.ca.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A substitution at position
-75 of the apoA-I gene promoter raises HDL cholesterol
(HDL-C) levels by examining the effect of this polymorphism in
French Canadians, a relatively genetically homogeneous
population. Among 308 women, carriers of the A allele displayed
12% and 10% higher mean plasma HDL-C and apoA-I concentrations,
respectively, than did noncarriers. Among 345 men, no effect of the A
allele was noted. The frequency distribution of HDL-C levels in
women carrying the A but not the G allele appeared bimodal, with
one peak corresponding to the mean of the noncarriers and a second to
higher HDL-C. Thus it appears that only a subset of A alleles
confers high HDL-C levels. This hypothesis was supported by data from
four kindreds within which some but not all A alleles segregated
with hyperalphalipoproteinemia. The data suggest that the A
substitution in the apoA-I gene promoter does not directly confer high
HDL-C levels but may be in linkage disequilibrium with other sequence
polymorphism(s) at this locus in a subset of alleles that raise
HDL-C levels.
Key Words: hyperalphalipoproteinemia genetic polymorphism HDL cholesterol apoA-I gene
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A number of studies have suggested that a G/A polymorphism at position -75 (relative to the transcription start site) in the promoter of the apoA-I gene is associated with variability in HDL-C levels. In a sample of 96 healthy men, Jeenah et al6 have observed a higher prevalence (.25) of the A allele in men with plasma apoA-I levels greater than the 90th percentile than in those with lower levels (.11); carriers of the A allele had mean plasma HDL-C concentrations 20% higher than noncarriers. In contrast, Pagani et al7 found no effect of the A allele in 108 men, but the A allele was significantly less prevalent in the lowest 10th percentile of HDL-C levels in 136 women. Paul-Hayase et al8 showed that in 162 boys and young men the A allele was associated with significantly higher (4.5%) apoA-I levels than was the G allele. Because the A substitution creates an inverted DNA sequence repeat homologous to previously characterized functional regulatory elements, it is hypothesized that the substitution itself may be functionally important, perhaps by increasing the activity of a transcriptional activator.6 7
However, the issue of whether the A substitution itself is directly responsible for these associations of the A allele with higher HDL-C levels is controversial. Smith et al9 found the A allele to be associated with significantly lower (11%) apoA-I production rates in vivo in 54 subjects, with lower rates of transcription in vitro and no differences in HDL-C or apoA-I levels. Tuteja et al10 have found that in vitro transcriptional differences between the A and G alleles depend on the length of promoter DNA used for transfection, such that the A allele is associated with lower transcription when 330 bp is used but with no differences if 1500 bp is used. Finally, Angotti et al11 have shown the A allele to be associated with higher transcription in vitro regardless of the length of the promoter used in the assay.
More recently, Barre et al12 have failed to observe any effect of the A allele on HDL-C levels in 205 women and 204 men. These authors suggest that the A substitution itself is not responsible for the apparent effect of the A allele on previously reported HDL-C and apoA-I levels but that this effect might be due to linkage disequilibrium between the A substitution and other DNA sequences that may regulate apoA-I plasma levels. The present study attempts to resolve the apparent inconsistencies among the above studies and to address the hypothesis of Barre et al12 by examining the frequency distribution of HDL-C levels in carriers and noncarriers of the A allele in French Canadians, a population shown to be relatively genetically homogeneous.13 14
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In addition to this group of subjects, four families in which
hyperalphalipoproteinemia segregated were studied. Two of these
involved subjects with familial
hypercholesterolemia. In family 1, familial
hypercholesterolemia is due to the >10-kb
deletion of the LDL receptor gene16 ; in family 2, to the
apoB Arg3500
Gln substitution.17 18 19
The protocol for this study was approved by the institutional ethics committee, and subjects participated after their informed consent was obtained.
Lipoprotein Analysis
Plasma was isolated from the venous blood of fasting subjects.
Lipoproteins were separated by ultracentrifugation
at d=1.006 g/mL to obtain VLDL and by precipitation of
apoB-containing lipoproteins in the d>1.006 g/mL fraction
to separate LDL from HDL.20 HDL2 and
HDL3 were measured after dextran sulfate
precipitation.21 Plasma and lipoprotein
cholesterol and TG concentrations were determined by using
enzymatic methods on an automated analyzer (Abbott biochromatic
analyzer, model 100, Abbott Laboratories). ApoA-I was measured
by electroimmunoassay on agarose gels (SEBIA). Lipoprotein lipid
determinations conformed to standard Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention requirements.
DNA Analysis
DNA was extracted from white blood cells by using an Applied
Biosystems 340A extractor. Oligonucleotides were
synthesized by the solid-phase triester method on a Pharmacia LKB
gene assembler plus DNA synthesizer. A 370-bp region of human apoA-I
gene promoter region was polymerase chain
reactionamplified22 from 200 to 500 ng of human
genomic DNA with primers 5'-CGGATCCCTGCCCACACACTCCCATGGAG-3'and
5'-GGAATTCTGAGCTGGGGAGCCAGAGTGAC-3' at 96°C for 1 minute and 68°C
for 3 minutes with a final extension of 7 minutes at 68°C. The
reaction product (5 µL) was digested with Msp I (GIBCO
BRL) according to the recommendations of the manufacturer. Digestion
products were electrophoresed on 1.8% NuSieve (FMC
BioProducts) agarose gels. Substitution of A for G results in the
loss of an Msp I site, ie, a 289-bp band indicates the A
allele and bands of 176 and 113 bp indicate the G allele. The
Xmn I restriction polymorphism at the apoA-I/C-III/A-IV
locus was determined by polymerase chain reaction.23
Genotyping of the apoA-I/C-III/A-IV locus was also accomplished by
sizing analysis of a
(Ca(Tb))c repetitive element in the
third intron of apoC-III.24 Alternatively, alleles
were sized by amplification with HEX-labeled primer and
fluorescence detection on a model 373A automated DNA sequencer
(Applied Biosystems).
Statistical Analysis
Statistical analyses were performed with
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS SYSTEM software (SAS
Institute, Inc). Data are reported as mean±SEM. Because no significant
correlation between age and plasma HDL-C levels was noted, HDL-C levels
were not adjusted for age in men. Plasma HDL-C concentrations were
adjusted in women by adding the residuals of the regressions of HDL-C
on TG and age to the sample mean, and in men on TG only. Multiple
linear regression revealed no effect of exogenous hormones in women nor
of tobacco use in men or women after adjustment for TG. Differences
between means were tested with a Student's t test.
Significance testing for skewness of frequency distributions was done
with a one-tailed t test
(df=
).25 Bimodality was assessed by
2 testing of the log maximum-likelihood
statistics generated for a single normal distribution and a mixture of
two distributions with equal or unequal SDs.26
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A substitution at position -75 of the apoA-I gene
promoter.6 7 The alleles with and without the A
substitution were designated as A and G alleles, respectively. In
men and women the prevalence of the A allele was .16 and .15,
respectively. This population sample did not deviate from
Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium for the genotypes AA, AG, and GG
(
2=0.41 and 0.33 for women and men,
respectively). In 345 men and 308 women, plasma HDL-C and apoA-I
concentrations were significantly inversely correlated with plasma TG
concentrations (R2=.29 and .15,
respectively, P<.0001). Plasma TG-adjusted
HDL-C was positively correlated with age in women
(R2=.03, P<.0008) but not in
men.
A+ women displayed 12% higher average plasma HDL-C than
did A- women (P<.001) (Table 1
). In addition, the mean plasma apoA-I concentration in
A+ women was 10% higher than that in A-
women. Plasma HDL-C and apoA-I levels in A+ and
A- men were indistinguishable. Thus, in female but not
male French Canadians the A base substitution in the apoA-I gene
promoter is associated with elevated plasma HDL-C levels.
|
To look for a gene-dosage effect, plasma HDL-C and apoA-I levels in
subjects homozygous and heterozygous for the A allele were compared
(Table 1
). In women, no evidence for a gene-dosage effect of the A
allele on HDL-C was apparent. Although plasma apoA-I levels tended
to be higher (5%) in female A allele homozygotes than
heterozygotes, the difference was not significant. HDL-C and apoA-I
levels in men homozygous for the A allele were higher (10% and
8%, respectively) than those in heterozygotes, but this difference was
not significant (Table 1
).
Exogenous Influences on HDL-C
Because smoking has been reported to be an important variable
in determining the effect of the A allele on HDL-C
levels,27 the proportion of smokers in each group was
compared. Among A+ women, 25% of the 56 subjects for whom
the information was available were smokers; among A-
women, 31% of 155 subjects smoked. Among A+ men, 30% of
82 were smokers; among A- men, 23% of 198 were smokers.
Thus, no differences in the proportion of smokers were observed between
the A- and A+ subject groups.
The proportion of women taking oral contraceptives was similar in A+ (7 of 49, 14%) and A- (24 of 148, 16%) subjects for whom this information was available. In addition, none of the A+ and 10 of the A- women were taking hormone replacement therapy. In the current sample, neither smoking nor hormone use contributed significantly to interindividual variability in plasma HDL-C levels.
HDL-C Distribution in A+ and A- French
Canadian Subjects
The distribution of adjusted HDL-C levels among A+
women was consistent with a mixture of two normal distributions
(
2=10.2, 2 df, P<.01
versus a unimodal model) with peaks (means) at 50 and 77 mg/dL. The
latter value corresponds to approximately the 95th percentile of HDL-C
levels in this sample of French Canadian women. In contrast, this
distribution among A- women was skewed (Fig 1
), with a mean of 52 mg/dL HDL-C. For the
A- women, no evidence for bimodality of the
log-transformed data was apparent (
2=1.2
versus a unimodal model). The distribution in A- but not
A+ men was skewed, with a mean of 46 mg/dL for both (Fig 1
). No evidence for bimodality was obtained in either group
(
2=3.0 and 2.1 for A+ men and
log-transformed distributions in A- men,
respectively).
|
The apparently bimodal distribution of plasma HDL-C levels among women
carrying the A allele suggests that only a subset of A alleles
confers a tendency to higher HDL-C levels. In an effort to further
define such an allele, we examined the effect of the Xmn
I polymorphism, which has been suggested as being in linkage
disequilibrium with the A substitution.6 8 This
polymorphism is located in the 5' flanking region of the apoA-I
gene
3.7 kb upstream of the transcription start site.28
Discordance between genotypes at the apoA-I/C-III/A-IV locus as
defined by the Msp I or Xmn I sites was observed
in only 19 women and 29 men. The effect of the rare Xmn I
allele on plasma HDL-C levels in heterozygous men and women was
similar to that of the rare Msp I (A) allele (data not
shown).
A+ alleles could be distinguished within four families
in which hyperalphalipoproteinemia is vertically transmitted with an
A+ allele (Fig 2
). The A allele has
been introduced twice in each kindred, and alleles at the
apoA-I/C-III/A-IV locus are identified by the size of the polymerase
chain reaction fragment (in base pairs) containing variable numbers
of dinucleotide repeats from intron 3 of the apoC-III
gene24 (Fig 2
). Within each kindred, one A allele
appears to segregate with high HDL-C percentiles that correspond to the
second peak in the density distribution of HDL-C levels among
A+ individuals (Fig 1
), and another does not (Table 2
). The mean HDL-C percentiles associated with the
former and latter classes of A allele were significantly different
(88th and 50th, respectively; Table 2
). Interestingly, some A
alleles appear to confer high HDL-C levels even in men within these
families. Thus, these families present evidence for a subset of
A-containing alleles segregating with high plasma HDL-C levels.
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A substitution at position -75 in the apoA-I gene
promoter confers high plasma HDL-C and apoA-I concentrations. However,
much of the data on the function of this substitution in vitro are not
consistent with this hypothesis. The apparent HDL-Craising
effect of the A allele could result from linkage disequilibrium or
from other artifacts inherent in association studies carried out in
genetically heterogeneous populations.29 On
the other hand, the historic and demographic circumstances leading to
relatively low genetic heterogeneity in the French
Canadian population have been described,14 and molecular
genetic evidence of genetic founder effects for numerous diseases in
this population has been reported.13 30 31 32 33 34 As such, the
French Canadian population presents the potential to clarify the
currently controversial issue of whether the G
A substitution at
position -75 in the apoA-I gene promoter (A allele) is directly
responsible for its observed association with high plasma HDL-C
concentrations. The prevalence of the A allele in the present group of French Canadians (.15) is similar to that reported in a large study of populations from 12 European countries35 but slightly lower than that seen in populations from the United States (.2012 and .188 ). However, the present study suggests that the effect of this polymorphism on plasma HDL-C and apoA-I concentrations in French Canadian women vastly exceeds those reported in other populations, ie, 14% and 9% in the present study for HDL-C and apoA-I versus 2% to 5% in European populations35 and no effect in a US study.12 In contrast to the situation in women, no differences were observed in plasma HDL-C or apoA-I concentrations between French Canadian men with and without the A allele. The presence in women and absence in men of the effect of the A allele on HDL-C levels are in agreement with the results from the large European study.35
In the present study, notable differences in the frequency distributions of HDL-C levels between carriers and noncarriers of the A allele were observed. Plasma HDL-C levels in women without the A allele displayed a skewed distribution consistent with 1 mean and 1 SD, while those in A allele carriers were distributed bimodally, with one peak corresponding to the mean of the noncarrier women and a second corresponding to the 95th percentile. These observations suggest that only a subset of A alleles confers high HDL-C levels in women.
A second line of evidence against the functional importance of the A promoter substitution is the lack of an apparent gene-dosage effect. If the A substitution increases the rate of apoA-I biosynthesis, one would expect to see a greater effect in subjects homozygous for the A allele. In previous studies, as in the present study, the low prevalence of the A allele has made this question difficult to address, and in most studies the HDL-C levels of A allele homozygotes have not been reported separately from heterozygotes. Among the unrelated subjects in the present study, eight female and seven male A allele homozygotes were found. In female homozygotes, HDL-C levels were indistinguishable from those in heterozygotes, while in male homozygotes they displayed a nonsignificant tendency to be higher compared with heterozygotes or noncarriers of the A allele. In both sexes, plasma apoA-I levels in A allele homozygotes tended to be nonsignificantly higher than those in heterozygotes. Thus, although small numbers may limit interpretation of these results, no evidence for a gene-dosage effect of the A allele could be detected in these French Canadian subjects. This result is in agreement with that of Barre et al,12 who found no effect of the A allele on HDL-C levels in a US population sample.
The G
A substitution in the apoA-I gene promoter was first identified
by cloning DNA from a subject in whose family the rare allele for
the apoA-I Xmn I restriction fragment length
polymorphism segregated with high apoA-I levels.6 The
A allele has also been observed to be in strong linkage
disequilibrium with the Xmn I 2 allele in one other
population.8 To explore the hypothesis that only a subset
of A alleles may confer high HDL-C levels, the Xmn I
restriction fragment length polymorphism of the apoA-I/C-III/A-IV
locus was examined in French Canadians. The data do not differentiate
between the effects of the Xmn I restriction fragment length
polymorphism and the A substitution.
In a further effort to distinguish between A alleles that do and do not confer high plasma HDL-C levels, we identified suballeles with a polymorphic dinucleotide repeat in intron 3 of the apoC-III gene.24 To overcome the large amount of allelic polymorphism we observed in our sample of unrelated French Canadians (data not shown), we studied four families in which the A allele was introduced more than once. In each family evidence was presented for an A allele that segregated with hyperalphalipoproteinemia and one with no apparent effects on HDL-C levels. Although these analyses were perhaps limited by the small number of carriers of a specific A allele within one family, the data support the hypothesis that only a subset of A alleles confers high HDL-C levels.
The present study presents three lines of evidence that the
observed association of the G
A substitution in the apoA-I gene
promoter, with its high plasma apoA-I and HDL-C levels, is unlikely to
result from a direct effect of this polymorphism on HDL
metabolism. First, no gene-dosage effect was detected.
Second, HDL-C levels among men and women with the A allele were
bimodally distributed with one peak corresponding to the sample mean
and a second corresponding to higher levels. Finally, within each of
four families, hyperalphalipoproteinemia segregated with only a subset
of A alleles. One possible explanation for these results is that
some A alleles contain additional sequences that confer a negative
effect on HDL-C levels. More likely, however, is that for a subset of
alleles, the A substitution is in linkage disequilibrium with other
sequences at the apoA-I/C-III/A-IV locus that raise HDL-C levels.
Elucidation and analysis of sequence difference(s) between the
different A alleles will address this possibility.
| Selected Abbreviations and Acronyms |
|---|
|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Received March 16, 1995; accepted July 19, 1995.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A transition) in the -78 position of the
apolipoprotein A-I promoter increases transcription efficiency.
J Biol Chem. 1994;269:17371-17374. This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. M Ordovas Genetic interactions with diet influence the risk of cardiovascular disease Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, February 1, 2006; 83(2): 443S - 446S. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Q. Yang, C.-Q. Lai, L. Parnell, L. A. Cupples, X. Adiconis, Y. Zhu, P. W. F. Wilson, D. E. Housman, A. M. Shearman, R. B. D'Agostino, et al. Genome-wide linkage analyses and candidate gene fine mapping for HDL3 cholesterol: the Framingham Study J. Lipid Res., July 1, 2005; 46(7): 1416 - 1425. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. M Ordovas, D. Corella, L A. Cupples, S. Demissie, A. Kelleher, O. Coltell, P. W. Wilson, E. J Schaefer, and K. Tucker Polyunsaturated fatty acids modulate the effects of the APOA1 G-A polymorphism on HDL-cholesterol concentrations in a sex-specific manner: the Framingham Study Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, January 1, 2002; 75(1): 38 - 46. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. Huang, J. Sasaki, A. Matsunaga, H. Nanimatsu, K. Moriyama, H. Han, M. Kugi, T. Koga, K. Yamaguchi, and K. Arakawa A Novel Homozygous Missense Mutation in the Apo A-I Gene With Apo A-I Deficiency Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol., March 1, 1998; 18(3): 389 - 396. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
ATVB Home | Subscriptions | Archives | Feedback | Authors | Help | AHA Journals Home | Search Copyright © 1995 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use prohibited. |